Chris V.
Yelp
Having had at least two Yelp friends rave about this spot, my gelato cravings could only be staved off so long until I finally made my own visit. Today was the day.
Gelateria Uli is an awesome gelato shop in a pretty awesome covered outdoor walkway called the Spring Arcade Building. Several other food stops can be made here (and one was made by yours truly for lunch), but my eye was set on trying the flavors available from this gelato maker. I don't have just a sweet tooth, but a desire to experience what can be done with the medium of frozen desserts.
Gelato is smooth like ice cream, but tends to be less airy and more focused on the individually named flavors rather than the base. It's also more expensive, almost spectacularly so here with sizes ranging from kids' to medium unless you want to lug a pint to-go. If only I actually lived here so that I could stock up a freezer's worth...
I probably just tipped my hand that I really enjoyed what I had. They offer 16 flavors at a time, but they also rotate seasonally and perhaps even experimentally, not content with providing only traditional flavors or only the same things all the time. As with any frozen dessert crafter worth their salt(ed caramel), they offer samples welcomingly. Everything had a similarly smooth, soft mouthfeel (even the sorbets) but carried a distinct flavor, and certainly nothing felt too sweet or looked unnaturally colored. From subtler tastes such as California pistachio gelato and June Lady Peach sorbet, to black sesame gelato and coconut lemongrass sorbet, I enjoyed everything which I sampled.
However, they only offer limited flavor selections in the standard menu items here, so I had to make some tough choices, starting by not tasting absolutely everything so that I could expedite my decision-making. I got a small cup ($5.75) of espresso w/ chocolate waffle bits for my parents to share, and I picked out a medium cup ($7) of beet tarragon gelato, speckled nectarine sorbet, and chocolate sorbet for myself to devour (with a modicum of sharing, of course).
The espresso was definitely what you'd get in a strong coffee frozen treat, but with crunchy bits to add sweetness and texture. The beet tarragon was pretty fantastic, with a tempered but still prominent beet flavor and a tarragon accent. The nectarine sorbet has the particular flavor of concentrated fruit that you would expect. The chocolate sorbet is rich and certainly dark enough, certainly among my favorite chocolate desserts both frozen and otherwise. Price aside, it's hard to say that I've had definitively better.
(The following paragraph was lifted wholesale from my own review of Guisados.) Note on parking: next to the Arcade Building, there seems to be a lot for $8 max, but we instead went with valet parking for a $8 flat rate at nearby Hotel Alexandria, also on the same side of the street. The weekday lunch visit was surprisingly quick though, so perhaps a cheaper option would be available for a quick visit. Other lots are listed/mapped at web sites that can be Googled; metered street parking was filled up on this specific day, with the situation exacerbated by a filmmaking crew unloading set pieces and whatnot into the Arcade Building alleyway.
Gelateria Uli is a destination-worthy spot for anyone with a sweet tooth, and I will strive to return on my next vacation to try different flavors. They're definitely among the very best gelaterias which I've had the pleasure to try.