Unregular Pizza

Unregular Pizza has a deep, tangy sauce and a slightly thicker crust that could be a bit crispier. The basil added nice flavor to the vegetarian pizza but I wish there were more. The garlic bites make excellent croutons for a salad.

Delicious vegan pizza! I got the fiesta pizza (pizza with vegan cheese, peppers, and mushrooms) and it was perfection. The pizza was very flavorful and fresh - it was even garnished with fresh basil. It can difficult to find good tasting vegan pizza but this has got to be one of the best in New York City. Also want to say thank you to Daniel the cook for making the pizza and Daniel the cashier who was friendly and helpful. Sidenote: I asked for light vegan cheese on my pizza

I don’t really get the hype of this restaurant. The pizza is small, overpriced, and just OK. I got a grandma slice as well as a vodka slice. Even after the restaurant warmed it up, neither slice was that warm. The grandma slice tasted like it was missing salt, and the vodka slice, while good vodka sauce, didn’t feel satisfying enough. At $6 each slice, these were very small slices that should have been either twice the size or half the cost. Atmosphere is fine - super small spot with very limited seating. Service was also fine - we asked for some recommendations as it was our first time, and the employee was not friendly or helpful.

A fantastic selection of different premium ingredients. A perfect crispy crust. And inside seating available too.

I ordered a delivery tonight and I’m so glad I did! The slices were abundant and made with top quality ingredients! They were out of a Vodka Sauce slice and the Burraprosciutto that I ordered but they kindly wrote me a message on the box saying that they were sorry and put two slices of the same order available in (I called in advance to know if they deliver to the UWS and the kind guy on the phone accepted my order even if it was late). The Cafonata (with creamy burrata) is out of this world! The Burrazucchini is garlicky and deliciously sweet! What can I say? As an Italian I grew up eating loads of pizzas and Unregular stand out in the City! Tasty, full of flavor and very satisfying! Thank you guys! You’ve earned a new customer! Great discovery!

So yummy and delicious! I got the garlic bread, burrapizza cafonata, and the fried pasta alla vodka. Everything was so good!

Pizza was good, a little crispy for my liking on the bottom but that’s probably because of the dough, it was not overcooked. Small bench to sit inside for 3 people max A couple of different slices to choose from which is always nice… I’d say a bit pricey for sure (should be about $2-$3 less) but it was filling and I would go back again. Final verdict, I recommend everyone try at least once. Prices are in the pictures I posted for reference.

Great pizza! We liked most of the slices we got, and they were pretty crunchy under, which was great. The staff were nice and they had some sits available. Their pizzas are better than their other items, but overall I recommend this place, specially if you want a quick bite.

Best pizza especially the vodka pizza and garlic squares. Can't say enough positive things about this pizza place. A must try.

Pizza was absolutely delicious. The employees were and helpful. Ingredients were fresh and the place was super cute.

Food was good- cheese:ratio was good, hot and sweet, came fast, good vibes in restaurant!

This was so good! The bread is amazing! Sauce so yummy. I'm only mad I didn't have a chance to go back while I was visiting to get the prosciutto sandwich (only got bites of my brothers and no photo! Big mistake not getting one for myself!

Stopped by Unregular Pizza due to great reviews and was hoping to like this place. Sadly. It was the complete opposite. While the staff here are nice, pleasant and even offered samples of their apple cider. It did not make up for the bland, burnt, dried chicken vodka I had. The mini- chicken vodka was so horrible. The chicken slice was barely any chicken, definitely frozen chicken, not fresh and tasted like it was jerk chicken with breading. Additionally the bread on the bottom was completely black and burnt. Could not even eat it. Overall friendly staff, hence the 2 stars however the food was absolutely horrible. Three bites of the mini chicken parm not worth the $7 price tag at all.

Over a year ago I had visited Unregular Pizza in Union Square so when I saw there was one when I was hanging out in the UES I wanted to check it out. This location is pretty small, with enough seating for about six people (and maybe a couple people standing). The counter has pizzas on display behind glass so you can see what you get. The decor is bright and very 80's retro (including a few Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles action figures!). My order was taken quickly and my slices were out of the oven faster than I expected. This sounds like a good thing but honestly I would have liked them to have stayed in the oven a minute or two more but that's my personal preference. Your mileage may vary. I had a mushroom slice and it was great. I'm not generally a square slice fan but this one was great (just like the one I had in the Union Square location). Good crust, good sauce and a lot of mushrooms! I'd happily go back to Unregular Pizza any time.

I had been hesitant to come here because I thought it would be gimmicky. MAN WAS I WRONG. This place rocks! Their sauce and crust is killer here and you can't go wrong. I can't decide if I like the vodka or grandma peppina more but I have come back numerous times to get this. This place is such a great addition to the UES to add into my rotation. If you haven't tried it defintely give it a chance you won't be disappointed by any means. Every worker I've ever interacted with was so friendly!

I have passed here many times and never went in. Well yesterday that were doing an event with an app and they were giving out free slices under 6.00. Great way to get new customers in to the store like myself and my friend who came to meet me. I got a Grandma peppina (V) Mozzarella, tomato sauce, parmigiano, house garlic olive oil and my friend got a slice of the vodka sauce pizza I think. This is a small place, but it is on a busy street so it deff gets foot traffic. They have four very small indoor tables and bench/ seats to sit and enjoy the pizza. The worker that helped my friend and I seemed nice. I deff would come back here and try other of their pizzas. Everything looked and smelled wonderful! If you ever walk by here deff stop in and enjoy a slice.

Amazing! So freakin tasty! Lots of help deciding which slice option to take from Jay. They got a great lunch special - 2 slices and a drink.

I'm thrilled that Unregular Pizza has opened a new location on the Upper East Side! Having been a regular at their Union Square spot, I can confidently say they have brought the same excellent quality to this neighborhood. The pizza here is a feast for both the stomach and the eyes. Every slice is consistently delicious, with that perfect balance of flavors and textures. My favorite is the one with hot honey and pepperonis, topped with a burrata! The service is quick and friendly, making every visit a pleasure. It's conveniently located near my Pilates studio, which makes it a perfect spot for a post-workout treat. If you're in the area, you definitely need to check out this new gem!

Great little spot with really unique varieties. The pizza is very good! We love the pepperoni and grandma peppina.

Fresh, amazing spot, incredible food and atmosphere/service, perfect addition to the neighborhood!

Great pizza in the area. Nice vegan options for my husband:) trying vodka slice today

Friendly service and pizza is delicious. I tried the margarita and vodka slice. $6 each and it's very good. The margarita is more salty and you taste a bit of the tartness from the tomatoes. It has a slight crunch and the vodka slice is very creamy and definitely my favorite. The seating is very tight and you have to squeeze in to get to the backseat. No bathroom.

Pizza good, friendly workers, but no bathroom..... if that's standard for most NYC pizzerias, then make it a filter option on Yelp searches.

New Roman style pizza chain. Small restaurant with 2 or 3 tight tables indoors and a few outdoors. Not a place to linger over a meal. Good selection of slices, salads and sandwiches. We sampled the menu. My wife had the veggie festa and the unmushroom. I tried the diavolona and the meat dream. The pizza was very good, but wasn't hot. We live 30 seconds away and the cheese on the pizza was mostly solid. Sidebar: I tried hot honey for the first time on the diavolona. I'm not a fan. We would definitely order from here again- make sure that the pizza is heated through.

Great first experience at the new UES location! Lots of good looking slices to choose from. Regular slices (non-burrata) are $4.50-$7. I had the grandma peppina (essentially a plain grandma spice) and the chicken out (chicken, roasted tomatoes, mozzarella and pesto). The grandma was very saucy; the sauce is good so I didn't mind! The chicken out was a bit dry. I may add some more of my pesto to it. The employee taking orders was very friendly and helpful. There are several tables inside and outside. Now they need to open the bakery nearby!!

Good pizza place which has replaced Farinella. They have square rectangular slices. Lots of slightly non traditional options but tasty. Pesto and chicken was a good one. They also have a full burrata on certain slices and the option to add it to any other slice !

The pizza is soooooo good. Ingredients are super fresh, pricing is very good. Feels like I am in the air. That's not an exaggeration, Staff is very friendly and gave good recommendation.

Pizza flavors are good. We got the unmushroom pizza, pizza alla vodka, and the burrata pizza. Only problem is that either the oven is not hot enough when they reheat it or they don't put it in long enough. The middle of the burrata was cold. Yes, we ate there so it's not like the pizza was cold by the time we brought it home.

Made a quick visit to the city for some medical tests and to visit a friend....on the way home, discovered this place - famished, purchased several items - very pleased with the variety of choices, particularly vegetarian and vegan - unique and distinctive title - very pleased with the food - highly recommended!

Delicious, such a great concept. So much variety. I had the grandma peppina. Definitely Check it out!

Small space with a few small tables and quick service. Flavors for their specialty spices worked well, with the balsamic fig and burrata standing out, albeit a bit pricey.

It is a small place but they have a few tables against the wall. The place is well lit and the food is good. The employees are nice and when your food is ready they either bring it to you or ask who ordered which slice of pizza. Depending on how busy the place is they will also chat a bit if you like. The store has both vegan and regular pizza

Amazing slides and great size. Very quick service and they give you a smile too. Very reasonable prices.

The pizza hits the spot but I am a bit annoyed about the lunch special. The sign outside says "two slices and a drink 10.99." I go in there is no lord info about the special. I order two slices and a drink and go to pay and the server said it's only "the first two pizzas you see over there" and pointed quickly. There is no sign that says that inside or outside, so then I'm stuck paying $18 when I could have just canceled a slice, but she had already put the pizzas in the oven. I've been going frequently but now I'm very disappointed. It should be clearly stated what pizzas are available for the lunch special.

When you're spending $7 for a single slice of pizza it would be cool to not have to pay for water. On a hot day, they want you to buy bottled water and will not give you tap water. The pizza is decent but overpriced. I would not recommend eating in, unless you're alone. The little triangular tables are too small for more than 1 person to sit at.

I was hoping I'd really like this place -- I miss PQR -- but our first delivery from the was only so so. The pizza arrived tepid and soggy. Much of the menu wasn't available and it was only 8:00 on a Friday night. The the person who took my order was not particularly helpful.

Delicious, some unique options and reasonably priced. The mushroom pizza was especially good. I've been several times.

We got few slices of margaritas take out Not to mention was barely warm 3 blocks walk considering it's over 90 hot day. It was horrible couldn't eat I feel bad to use word "disgusting" Please please get some help maybe you can learn how to make pizza .. My Best ...

Super friendly staff and probably one of the best pizzas you'll find on the UES. The diavolona is DELICIOUS!!

Great Nutella pizza!! Great cheese pizza!! Everything great. Cool, different flavors and toppings!

Omg the burrata margherita pizza was probably one of the best, if not the best, pizza I've ever had. There was no question that it was fresh. The people working were super nice and the atmosphere was modern, colorful, and fun. There are only about 3 tables but we lucked out and we're able to sit while we ate. 10/10 place and would definitely make this a regular spot.

Really good and fun and creative slice options. Genesis at the counter was super helpful with answering questions about slices. The lemon basil Sicilian slushy was good and refreshing