Seyean Y.
Yelp
I lived at Upper West for 15 months (July 2023-October 2024), and while there were some good aspects, the negatives--especially the management--were hard to ignore.
As a student, I appreciated having amenities like study spaces and a year-round pool (rare in Utah with the snow). However, the pool was constantly shut down because of a few residents breaking the rules--usually for things like broken glass. Rather than addressing the individuals causing the problems, management resorted to blanket punishment. They even sent out an email threatening to close the pool entirely for everyone. This approach was completely unfair to those of us who followed the rules, especially considering the high fees we paid for these amenities. Management should take responsibility for identifying and holding rule-breakers accountable instead of punishing the entire community.
To make matters worse, there were recurring issues with people and even kids jumping the fences to access the pool and rooftop areas. It seemed like these intrusions weren't being addressed seriously, which only added to the frustration of paying premium fees for amenities that often became unusable due to mismanagement and lack of security.
The handling of the deposit itself was another issue. I went out of my way to get the paint code for the apartment so I could repaint the walls before moving out, only to be charged for repainting anyway. On top of that, the move-out package essentially told us not to bother cleaning because "it won't meet their standards." So why bother? It felt like they were setting tenants up to lose their deposits no matter what.
The issues with management didn't stop there. When I moved in, I was told I'd receive two key fobs for my two-bedroom apartment but only got one. Seven months later, I requested a second key fob and was charged $50 for it, even though it should have been free from the start. The leasing office staff promised I'd be reimbursed for the $50 if I returned the key at move-out, which I did. After moving out, my account balance was still around $130 after they took my $500 security deposit, and they refused to reimburse the $50 for the fob. Their excuse? The guy who made the promise no longer works there, and there wasn't a written agreement.
When I contacted the accounts payable team about this, I was told not to reach out to the leasing office again because, apparently, this was a done deal. I couldn't let that go--this was just ridiculous. Management should be accountable for what their staff tells tenants. It's wrong to put the responsibility on tenants to know all the ins and outs of what they should or shouldn't expect, especially when the leasing office is giving out misleading or conflicting information.
The parking situation was another headache. I paid extra for a reserved parking spot, but the public parking around the community was a mess. Fire lanes were constantly blocked by illegally parked cars. Management claims they enforce towing, but it only happens when the city pressures them. During my time there, they did one mass towing event that took care of the problem for a month, but after that, it went right back to chaos.
It's funny because when I first inquired about moving in, they admitted that people park where they shouldn't--like in the fire lanes--and suggested I could park there too if I didn't want to pay for parking, but I'd have to "be careful" and park at my own risk of being towed. They also mentioned I could park at the adjacent TRAX lot, which isn't meant for residential use at all--it's for TRAX users only, not for free residential parking.
The most frustrating thing is that management only seems to enforce the rules when it benefits them. Whether it's punishing everyone for the actions of a few, failing to follow through on their own promises, or not taking responsibility for their mistakes, it's clear that the rules don't apply to them the same way they do to tenants.
Between the unfair fees, poor communication, and unprofessional handling of concerns, I wouldn't recommend Upper West. The amenities might look good on paper, but the way management operates will leave you feeling taken advantage of.
Congrats for reading all the way through! If you're considering moving here, I'd strongly advise looking elsewhere if you want a fair, accountable, and well-run community.