AJ L.
Yelp
For their sauces alone, I'm willing to say Via Rosa puts out some of the best-tasting food on the island. All of the sauces I've tried there taste like something homemade, like they took a good deal of time and effort to make. Definitely a step above the average around here. That said, for the price, the pizza and pasta itself fell a little bit short of expectations.
The pizza dough itself is very thin, very crisp, and has a nice flavor. Their marinara, like all their other sauces, is bright and tasty. Despite this, their margherita pizza was seriously underwhelming - the way the basil was on the pizza was a little sad but the real killer was the apparent lack of fresh mozzarella - it tasted a lot more like a parmesan pizza than anything else. Just seemed like a really strange thing to skimp out on, and based on other pictures it seems like going super light on the cheese may just be the standard here. In any case, I think there are better places to go for pizza on the island, thin-crust or otherwise (especially for the price!!)
I didn't really take any particular issue with the noodles themselves (they weren't *unpleasant* to eat or anything) but the texture wasn't amazing and they've just never really impressed. Additionally, it's a little strange how long it took to get food given how fast fresh pasta takes to cook, their having sauces pre-prepared, and the size of their kitchen. But if you order ahead of time this probably isn't much of an issue - they seem to be doing a lot of take-out business.
Cannoli was ok, not very sweet. Nice of them to have it at such a low price, one of my dining companions felt sure they were store-bought but I would probably still get one again.
Altogether, it's far from bad food, and the location is pretty nice - they give you a good deal of options for take-home food, I like their "market" section. I'm not sure if I'd describe it as a "must-try" place - even at its best, it feels expensive for what you get. Still, I'd say it's one of the better restaurants on Bainbridge if money is no object. Kind of an iconic little location (Rolling Bay) to visit off the beaten path if you're a tourist. People definitely like this place for a reason.