Mikhala F.
Yelp
This was an experience in the best way possible. A hidden (on purpose) gem right in Lyn Lake.
Between Lyndale and Aldrich Ave on Lake Street is a little alleyway--take it. About 1/3 the way down (heading towards W 31st), veer left into a little pocket where there is a few parking spots, a dumpster, and a few doors. Go in to your left and you'll see a grey door with a slat across-eye level. This is how the bouncer will check to see who you are. If you come on a popular evening or weekend time, you may also find a long line, which will obviously give it away.
Be ready to show IDs--21 and over only. I highly recommend making a reservation if you're planning to go--we got a high-top for four at 6:30pm on a Friday evening, but wanted a booth (you get served out of a framed mirror on the wall!). Reserve a table at: reservations@volsteads.com.
Upon entering, you go down the stairs and enter the magical world that awaits you. Dimly lit (like super dark--we used phone flashlights to read the menus), dark, Victorian decor, and couples whispering to each other while sipping cocktails makes the ambience everything and more.
Everyone who works here isn't just a waiter or waitress or food runner -- they play a character and a role in the experience. Our waiter was exceptional and spoke in hushed, distinctive formal tones that added to the atmosphere. He recommended cocktails and make sure our first experience here was nothing short of magical.
I got the Leave It To Me gin cocktail, which was pink and fun and boozy. The Matador is a strong tequila cocktail. The fog cutter is a fun and potent cocktail that comes in a unique glass. They were not overpriced at all and were delicious and fun.
We got the house chips (served with a french onion dip) and olives, which was a great start with the cocktails.
For dinner, we shared 4 small plates. shishito peppers, stuffed mushrooms, cauliflower, and meatballs. The stuffed mushrooms were delicious, and the cauliflower was perfectly done with delicious creamy cheese sauce.
We saw waiters come out of mirrors on the wall, found the telephone booth where if you have a private party, you enter into a secret room, and ooh-ed and aah-ed at the bartenders whipping up fabulous drinks.
10/10 recommend for a friend coming into town you're trying to wow, or something a local who has "done it all" has never done, and everyone in between.