Tom P.
Yelp
What started out as a 4 star review continued to go downhill. I want to like this place, and as a resident on the waterfront who loves supporting the restaurants here, I will come back to give it another chance.
Seating was prompt and the guy at the door is an ambassador for the place. Friendly, ready to answer questions, and a spare menu in hand to let folks peruse.
I like the look of the place. They've added more social seating on the balcony from the previous establishment. Definitely dog friendly with lots of water bowls at the ready.
The menu is better than average bar fare and I was happy to see that they offer gyros, which I think is unique at the Wharf. I also upgraded from the fries to the onion rings. This is where things started to go downhill. The food came out promptly, and the Gyro *looked great. Tasty meat, fresh veggies, and tzatziki. But when I took a bite something was off and I picked it out immediately. They'd used blue cheese instead of feta cheese, and wow that made an overpowering impression. Also, the onion rings were overdone (which I can forgive).
Probably what bugged me the most is that my server disappeared for long periods. Perhaps she had a lot of tables (the place was busy) so I'll give her the benefit of the doubt. But when the check finally came (which I waited 30 minutes for) I noticed that the bill comes with 20% gratuity added. It feels a little sneaky because the tip line doesn't say, "Additional tip." And I get it... tipping culture in the city can be spotty. But I'd feel better with the establishment paying a living wage, saying that, then leaving an option for additional tip. The current way of doing it seems shady.
This first experience was rough. Like I said, I'll give it another shot and either update or confirm.