Miriam I.
Yelp
Feb 11, 2025
Tried Wilder's, having waited longer than usual - we like trying new dining establishments, and have enjoyed the other restaurants in the group to which this one belongs. For the most part, our experience was a positive one. First of all, and best of all - the service. Our server was warm, efficient, and attentive. We benefited from her professionalism, and it added greatly to the experience. Next, the ambiance. The dining space is not terribly large (13 tables), but the tables are well laid-out, and in general very comfy. Lighting was on the low side, but not so dark as to interfere with our ability to read the menu (a pet peeve - glad they avoided this pitfall). And most important, the food. I ordered the French onion soup, while the co-diner got the house salad. The soup was first-rate, and the salad was - as requested - lightly dressed. Rolls were also provided - rosemary milk, made in house. For entrees, we both got the short ribs. Meat was tender, and very tasty. The main course was accompanied by whipped potatoes - quite nice. We also ordered the truffled carrots - excellent. We each got a glass of red wine (one Cabernet, one Pinot noir), and were quite pleased with them. The problem with the main course came when the servers (one male, one female) brought small pitchers of Jus, and then proceeded to empty the entire contents over the short ribs, resulting in drowning the meat, rather than complimenting it. To make matters worse, the taste of the sauce did not enhance the meat, which was quite flavorful on its own. We ended up requesting an extra plate, and spooning as much of the jus as possible onto it. Not the result we were looking for. Coffee was French press - quite nice. For dessert, we ordered a lemon tart to share. This was not exactly what we anticipated. The crust - made from ground almonds - was very nice. The filling consisted of some type of lemon flavored creamy mousse, with 4 spherical orbs of meringue. Not terrible, but not great. If the chocolate cake did not contain peanut butter, I think we would have gotten that instead, and would have preferred it. The diners at the next table over got the New York strip, and raved about the quality of the meat. Something to consider on a future visit. All in all, our first time at Wilder's was generally favorable, with a few missteps.