Yogurt Club

I tried the thick yogurt out of curiosity, and even though it wasn’t very sweet, it turned out to be surprisingly addictive. I kept thinking about it, so I went back again. This time, they were selling those chewy Dubai-style cookies I’d been seeing on Instagram — they had extra flavors, and every one was well made. I ended up eating a lot of cookies with the yogurt and bought several to take home as gifts. Next time, I definitely need to try the frozen yogurt!

Such a small and cute addition to the Upper East Side. The staff if super friendly and all the ordering is done through a kiosk. They do offer samples so you can figure out what you want. We had the flavor of the month, the matcha banana pudding, in both Greek yogurt and frozen yogurt base. Both were amazing. I’m so glad there’s a place with a Greek yogurt option as a base. It was thick with the right amount of flavor. The only thing to note is the price is a little steep. The two yogurts ran $25.

Wanted to try this place for so long and it did not disappoint. Froyo tasted amazing but the thick yogurt was BOMB. I truly dont understand the bad reviews it was genuinely so good and it wasnt even that thick. Prices are fare too, you pay for quality ingredients and amazing service, if its too expensive for you just go to a crappy place and get crappy yogurt☺️

Pricey a bit but its City, no complaint. Yogurt was fine, thick & tasty. Also, tried their Dubai chewy cookie (if I call it right).

Super nice!!! It was very clean and quiet when I went, and I really liked the ambiance of the shop. My total was about $15, but I also added extra stuff. I would go again if visiting NYC again 🩷 (phone was taken after I had eaten about 1/2 of my bowl)

got the frozen Greek yogurt! SO YUMMY. The worker was SO NICE (Hispanic girl with classes) she was so sweet and helpful. Guided me through the ingredients, as well as offered small samples. Just so kind, I really appreciate her help. Also, $13 for this is not bad at all. Do not understand the hate or the complaints. It’s really good.

The food itself wasn’t too bad, I was a bit worried about trying it out due to the reviews online, but was intrigued by the idea of dry yogurt. The food itself wasn’t too bad, I’d recommend the frozen yogurt over the Greek yogurt if you aren’t a big fan of it, because I found this too be much stronger than regular Greek yogurt normally is for some reason? For both a berry frozen yogurt and a strawberry pistachio yogurt, (both menu items) with an add-on of raspberries syrup on the strawberry one it came out at 27$ which for the area is not too bad for the serving size, which I think is pretty reasonable for the item. However I was a bit disappointed after realizing just now that the pistachio syrup/topping, was missing in the Greek yogurt 😭😭(the first picture is mine, and the 2nd is how it was supposed to be.)

Honestly love that there’s a healthy sweet treat option I can visit when I’m in UES! I liked the frozen yogurt (tart) the most. If you get the strained yogurt, you should try getting a syrup or a sweet topping because the texture is dry from getting the whey strained out. In terms of toppings, I highly recommend the honeycomb — they were so generous with the portion size!!

Back to my new favorite yogurt spot, for their limited December flavor. As you may have noticed, they've become even more generous with their topping portions after hearing customer feedback. They've also improved the texture of their dry Greek yogurt: it's now even creamier, almost like a scoop of healthy ice cream. It completely won me over, even though I usually prefer frozen yogurt! ＊Biscoff Banana Crunch Greek Yogurt $13 * I usually only see pistachio knafe, so this was my first time trying a biscoff version. The knafe had a gentle crunch and a buttery biscoff flavor that felt comforting without being too much. When it melts slightly into the salted caramel greek yogurt, the mix of crunchy and creamy textures was really soothing. I was expecting it to be way too sweet, but it wasn't! ＊Frozen Yogurt with Matcha Shell, Honeycomb, Peppermint, Strawberries $13.25 I went with the Greek tart flavor and it was perfectly tangy. I topped it with honeycomb, which instantly reminded me of the signature raw honeycomb at Yoajung, the famous froyo specialty shop in Korea. The waxy texture added a fun crunch to it. FYI peppermint and mini marshmallows are only here for December.

Quality: I got the thick greek yogurt. The yogurt and toppings were fresh. It is exactly as advertised dehydrated thick greek yogurt. Variety: a lot of toppings to choose from but all $1.50 or more. I got the pistachio knafe which is $3. Atmosphere/Cleanliness: clean small space with bench seating for 5 people max. Service: there's 2 self service kiosk which makes ordering really easy. My yogurt came out in under 3 minutes. There's also free cups of water which you definitely need to wash down the yogurt. Price: $16.88 including tax for one scoop and 5 toppings This place is definitely worth a try for those who REALLY love greek yogurt, but I would not come back because the price for the yogurt and toppings are ridiculous.

When you go through the door, the cashiers will offer you a taste test, and if you come in here wanting to get dry yogurt, you should definitely try it on the little spoon first. The texture will be extremely jarring (like a thick paste), and the taste is very plain. That said, once you pour on a bunch of toppings (we got honey, coconut, and peaches), it tastes decent. Like, it can be a hearty breakfast. But WOW is it dry. Also, the fact that adding toppings is a must to save the taste gets bad when you realize the toppings are $1.50 each. They are generous with the toppings, but they should definitely be $1 each at the most. We also tried the frozen yogurt, which I also found pretty underwhelming. I much prefer the froyo at Pinkberry. The yogurt here was just a bit melty and the tart flavor was still sweet. I think I just preferred something more tangy, but truly to each their own. My cousin did say that the owner had been taking note of what people were saying in their reviews and already making adjustments accordingly, which I think is actually very admirable and a good sign! I'm not sure if this is the best area for something like this, but it was nice to try it out.

I was surprised to see so many negative reviews. Yogurt Club is a frozen yogurt shop, not that different from Pinkberry or any other. You order at a kiosk. Yes, I found it to be expensive for what it is. The product was fine but not earth shatteringly amazing. The fun with frozen yogurt is the toppings and when you start adding these, the price really jumps quickly. This small yogurt with mochi, strawberries and chocolate she'll cost more than $10. I also tasted the regular yogurt and found it was just okay. I'd rather order the frozen yogurt.

I want to start with strained Greek yogurt is an acquired taste. I've never had it before so I'm not sure if I don't like it, or there are better places. I went on opening day and was able to get 1.5 scoops (to share with a friend) of the strained Greek yogurt before it sold out. Minus one star for the price to topping ratio. Our yogurt was almost $19 and paying $1.50 for each topping for the smallest amount is a terrible pricing structure. I'd rather pay by weight. I also think, if someone orders a lot of toppings, they should put it in a bigger cup to fit all of the toppings. Another minus one star for the hospitality. The owner, Krystal oh, was at the store on opening day. As the owner of the shop, I was surprised she wasn't talking and greeting the customers and gathering feedback. Instead, she was standing in the corner on her laptop. I think if she was gathering feedback in person, she wouldn't have had this much backlash. I may or may not go back for the frozen yogurt but would like to see if they change the pricing structure.

Been following the creator for a while and was excited to find out she opened during my trip here! It was super good and filling. Didn't think it was too dry, but I did stop by after they changed the consistency from when they first opened.

Loved the strained and frozen yogurt! The owner was so sweet and gave out goodies during the first week of the shop being open. Samples of the different yogurts were available, the place looked sanitary, and the staff was friendly. Although this place has had some drama surrounding the topping prices, the yogurt itself was great!

Wanted to try this new spot after hearing all the hype but boy was I disappointed. I get the concept of thick yogurt but what they're serving here is just dry like they've over-strained it. It's also extremely overpriced. I paid $1.50 for the tinest scope of grapes. It only had 2 whole grapes! Each scope was very stingy. In total, I paid $16 for a tiny cup that wasn't even full... service was mid at best. The servers barely greeted us with a smile. Overall, I could make this at home and make it better. I wouldn't recommend it to anyone to try.

I wrote a very helpful and neutral review on Google maps --3 stars --and it got deleted so now I'm docking one star off for literally deleting reviews that aren't spam and that are trying to help!!!!!!! Kind of arrogant copy and pasting my review here: As someone who eats dry yogurt all the time in china, i was slightly disappointed with how dry the yogurt was. I know this yogurt store just opened recently so I dont wish to be too harsh but i think there should be an option to choose either twice strained or once strained yogurt and also perhaps an option to mix the original greek with the dry greek since I tried my friend's swirled original with mine and switching between the two in between bites was a good balance. What also helped with the dryness was any fruit or sauce topping which made my bowl extremely pricey for 1.50 each topping. I spent 17 usd on a bowl that i had a lot of trouble eating :( which i dont think is reasonable even in this economy. I wish there was the option for one or two base free toppings bc i barely got to put any on mine before the price got too steep.

Ngl tried to like it but why am I paying for store bought yogurt and toppings for 1.50..... not worth the price or the service.

Absolutely disgusting. The moment I walked in I noticed the floors were disgusting and muddy. I'm not sure how the heck they thought it was okay to leave a restaurant looking like that, but I tried to look past that because I wanted to try the yogurt. I'm a big fan of frozen yogurt and even make my own bowls in the morning with Greek yogurt, but there was something unnecessarily tart and "off" tasting with what I got. Not to mention that it was dead in there, and the workers met me with no hospitality. Overall, the service was horrible. The environment was unsanitary, and the food was definitely not worth the unnecessarily inflated prices. If I could put zero stars I would.

I really wanted to like it, but paying $14 for the smallest cup of yogurt with barely any strawberries -literally about half a strawberry. Was very disappointing

Yogurt was very dry and thick, but it was ok with toppings. Definitely overhyped and overpriced though

extremely overpriced. the yogurt is insanely dry and is only decently swallowable when you add a bunch of sauces and toppings. $1.50 for each topping and getting a spoonful of cut up grapes is insane i do not recommend

I've never been to a place that was so overhyped. Insane prices ($1.50 per topping and they ive you such a small scoop) and it's just ran by a silly influencer. Trader Joe's thick and creamy yogurt was more tasty. Just make it at home for a fraction of the cost. You should not be relying on toppings to make yogurt taste good. I get it - it's just plain yogurt but there is nothing special about it. it's just strained and you can do that in the comfort of your home. I have no idea why this place is getting any positive review. I wrote a google review but it is not being shown so I am very suspicious of what the business is doing behind closed doors. Incredibly disappointed and I will not recommend to anyone.

I dont get the hype of this place. the yogurt was overprice and super dry. staff was rude as well

Worst frozen yogurt I've ever had. Did not have the Greek yogurt available so tried the normal vanilla yogurt. Was extremely overpriced (medium yogurt was 15 dollars) and the vanilla flavor was super artificial. I got mango and pineapple as toppings and they were not fresh and tasted like it was out of a can. Highly, highly recommend going anywhere else for frozen yogurt.

I went here just as it opened and I am absolutely hooked! I came back a week later and she changed the formula of the yogurt to be slightly creamier and I loved it even more. The toppings pair so well with the yogurt and it was delicious to eat! Krystal is so so sweet and I can't wait to come back.

The owner has a known reputation of having terrible integrity, the yogurt is absurdly expensive, and terrible service. Firstly, the Krystal (the owner) wiped all the negative reviews on google maps, it had a 2.5 star rating with 150 reviews on the weekend of the grand opening. Now its all gone. Krystal must have contacted google to wipe anything negative about it or something- which really shows what kind of person that runs this establishment is. Krystal is known for cutting corners and hiking up the price of things, as evident in her previous nail businesses. The yogurt is ridiculously expensive, priced at $7 for ONE scoop!!!!! The same size of an ice cream scooper!!!! The strained yogurt is completely inedible without toppings which are priced at $1.50 each. The honeycomb is another $3. The dubai chocolate drizzle is a whopping $4. This pricing is absurd, as your bowl can easily go over $20. The workers there were rude and impolite. Also, the yogurt isn't even made in house- it's only strained! you can strain yogurt yourself easily at home by scooping yogurt into a bowl and putting a paper towel under it!