The 12 Best Hotels in Key West

"Another Key West icon, Pier House made its name in the '70s as a haven for the creative set. Today, it's a sprawling resort right on the water, with plenty of activities, an excellent spa, and great dining options (including the bar where Jimmy Buffet had his first gig). Some rooms have that Old Florida classic décor—think plenty of rattan—but suites have patios or balconies, making them ideal for enjoying a Key West sunset. Beds and amenities are nice, too. Pier House is in the middle of it all, but once you're facing the ocean, you'll forget all about the hullabaloo on Duval Street." - Paul Rubio, Nancy DePalma