"Dark and woody, the Black Penny’s dimly-lit vibe evokes a pre-Thomas Edison era that remains true to the building’s 1830s roots. Don’t come to the Penny seeking wine or umbrella drinks (though it serves those, too) — this is a prime spot to sit at the wrap-around bar and sample off-the-beaten-path ales. An extensive beer menu divided into taste profiles helps to guide patrons." - Eater Staff