"A buzzy mini-market near Washington Square Park is carrying three flavors of a much-talked-about pie-crust-lattice–topped pint brand: Sweet Cherry Pie, Millionaire’s Shortbread (caramel ice cream and shortbread), and Coney Island Queen (sprinkles and bits of ice cream cone). The reviewer chose the Sweet Cherry Pie ($13) and was delighted by the cherry-and-vanilla ice cream and a hefty amount of buttery pie crust chunks mixed throughout. Pro tip preserved from the experience: “If you don’t see the flavor you want on the freezer shelf, ask if there are any more being stored downstairs.” — Stephanie Wu, editor-in-chief" - Nadia Chaudhury