P & M Classic Pizza and Restaurant

Italian restaurant · Hamilton Heights

1

@eater

"This two-decade old pizzeria bills itself as “A Taste of Italy in Harlem” — and it is indeed, with an extended menu of chicken, veal, seafood, and eggplant, with full dinners under $20. But most folks dash in for a slice, and the overwhelming favorite is the pepperoni, the sliced sausage vying with the profuse tomato sauce for pungency. Sicilian slices and calzones are also worth ordering." - Robert Sietsema

NYC’s Top Pizza Slices, Mapped - Eater NY
Robert Sietsema

1747 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10031 Get directions

pmclassicpizza.com

1 Postcard

See full details

More Places For You

Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop

Donut shop · Greenpoint

Step into this nostalgic bakery for old-school donuts and breakfast sandwiches, where the yeasted delights steal the show in a cozy, vintage setting.

23 Postcards

Old John's Luncheonette

Diner · Upper West Side

This classic American diner near Lincoln Center serves up hearty burgers and salads in a cozy vibe, with some trendy touches and delicious shakes.

22 Postcards

The Chef's Table at Brooklyn Fare

Fine dining restaurant · Hell's Kitchen

Chef's Table at Brooklyn Fare offers an exquisite 20-course tasting menu, masterfully blending French and Japanese flavors in a luxe setting that demands reservations.

35 Postcards

Mao Mao

Thai restaurant · Bedford-Stuyvesant

Nestled in Bushwick, this cozy eatery serves up enticing Thai street food alongside crafted cocktails, all within a dimly lit, cinema-like ambiance.

10 Postcards

Ray’s

Bar · Lower East Side

Ray's is the ultimate upscale dive, blending vintage charm with a lively bar scene, tasty cocktails, and a pool table for endless fun.

9 Postcards

Santa Fe BK

Southwestern restaurant (US) · Williamsburg

Chill vibes abound at this cozy Southwestern gem serving up creamy breakfast burritos and tasty green chile cheeseburgers that'll transport you to New Mexico.

11 Postcards

Guerra Paint & Pigment

Art supply store · Maspeth

Guerra Paint & Pigment is a treasure trove for artists, featuring a stellar selection of raw pigments and expert guidance to craft your perfect paint.

2 Postcards

Allbirds

Shoe store · SoHo

Step into Allbirds, where sustainable style meets a welcoming vibe, and slip into their super comfy footwear that's perfect for casual strolls in the city.

3 Postcards

Joong Koog Jip

Korean restaurant · Flushing

Bustling, no-frills hangout for Korean-style Chinese cuisine such as black soybean-paste noodles.

3 Postcards

Lucali

Pizza restaurant · Carroll Gardens

Experience stylish brick-oven pizza at this cozy, BYOB gem in Brooklyn, where the glowing reputation and all-star pies make the wait worthwhile.

53 Postcards