P & M Classic Pizza and Restaurant

Italian restaurant · Hamilton Heights

1

@eater

"This two-decade old pizzeria bills itself as “A Taste of Italy in Harlem” — and it is indeed, with an extended menu of chicken, veal, seafood, and eggplant, with full dinners under $20. But most folks dash in for a slice, and the overwhelming favorite is the pepperoni, the sliced sausage vying with the profuse tomato sauce for pungency. Sicilian slices and calzones are also worth ordering." - Robert Sietsema

NYC’s Top Pizza Slices, Mapped - Eater NY
Robert Sietsema

1747 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10031 Get directions

pmclassicpizza.com

1 Postcard

See full details

More Places For You

Sobre Masa

Mexican restaurant · Williamsburg

Nestled in Bushwick, Sobre Masa serves up a delightful taste of Mexico with handmade tortillas, inviting vibes, and a menu that keeps you coming back for more.

24 Postcards

Jane's Carousel

Amusement park ride · DUMBO

Nestled in Brooklyn Bridge Park, Jane's Carousel is a beautifully restored 1922 ride, offering timeless charm and stunning views of the skyline and bridges.

6 Postcards

Rosemary's

Italian restaurant · West Village

At Rosemary's in Greenwich Village, you’ll find a warm and inviting Italian eatery with seasonal dishes, house-made pastas, and a lovely rooftop farm.

11 Postcards

Pata Cafe

Thai restaurant · Elmhurst

Tucked away in Elmhurst, this cozy mom-and-pop Thai café offers authentic, homestyle dishes that are bursting with flavor and charm.

6 Postcards

Sweet Afton

Bar · Astoria

A lively Irish pub with a hip vibe, brick-&-beam interior, a garden and locally sourced food.

7 Postcards

Gotham Coffee Roasters

Coffee shop · Chelsea

Gotham Coffee Roasters is your go-to spot for top-notch artisanal brews and a cozy vibe, perfect for coffee aficionados in the heart of NYC.

1 Postcard

The Standard, East Village

Hotel · East Village

Tucked off Cooper Square in the East Village, this sleek high-rise hotel boasts airy rooms with city views, a chic restaurant, and a vibrant bar scene.

13 Postcards

Electric Burrito

Burrito restaurant · East Village

This unassuming gem serves up delicious California-style burritos with fresh ingredients and hearty portions, making it a go-to for burrito lovers in NYC.

15 Postcards

King Cole Bar

Bar · Midtown East

Step into this historic hotel bar for expertly crafted cocktails and a glamorous vibe, all beneath a stunning Maxfield Parrish mural.

9 Postcards

P. Johnson

Clothing store · SoHo

Tailor and clothier offering custom clothing for men and women in a laid-back setting.

1 Postcard