9

Big Gay Ice Cream

Permanently Closed

Big Gay Ice Cream

Permanently Closed
@eater
391,688 Postcards · 10,993 Cities

NYC Restaurant Closings in February 2025 - Eater NY

"An Upper West Side ice cream store that closed due to slow sales and high rent." - Nadia Chaudhury

https://ny.eater.com/2025/2/7/24356123/nyc-restaurant-closings-february-2025

Information

Soft serve ice cream, cookies, and unique donuts with toppings

salty pimp
soft serve
donuts
american globs
vegan ice cream
friendly staff
lgbtq+ friendly
rainbow flavors
Google Rating
3.9 (183)
Yelp Rating
3.4
Featured in The Infatuation
Featured in
Featured in Eater
Featured in
Featured in Grub Street
Featured in

516 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024 Get directions

$$

Order delivery
See Menu
Contactless accepted
LGBTQ friendly
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by Infatuation - Reviews
Big Gay Ice Cream by Infatuation - Reviews
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
See full details

9

Information

Soft serve ice cream, cookies, and unique donuts with toppings

salty pimp
soft serve
donuts
american globs
vegan ice cream
friendly staff
lgbtq+ friendly
rainbow flavors
Google Rating
3.9 (183)
Yelp Rating
3.4
Featured in The Infatuation
Featured in
Featured in Eater
Featured in
Featured in Grub Street
Featured in

516 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024 Get directions

$$

Order delivery
See Menu
Contactless accepted
LGBTQ friendly
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by Infatuation - Reviews
Big Gay Ice Cream by Infatuation - Reviews
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
Big Gay Ice Cream by null
See full details

More Places For You

Margot

Restaurant · Fort Greene

Seasonal menu with seafood, vegetables, pasta & cocktails

21 Postcards

Disco Birdies

Restaurant · Bedford-Stuyvesant

Burgers, fried chicken sandwiches, fries, and champagne

5 Postcards

Yasubee Authentic Ramen

Ramen restaurant · Chelsea

Authentic tsukemen and ramen with handmade noodles

1 Postcard

Mr. Nancy's

Bar · Ridgewood

Cocktails, chili dogs, karaoke, and a disco ball

3 Postcards

The Ripple Room

Bar · Lower East Side

Two-floor bar with pool tables and a retro vibe

6 Postcards

Pine & Polk

Grocery store · SoHo

Artisanal provisions shop with a speakeasy cocktail bar

5 Postcards

Juici Patties

Jamaican restaurant · Bedford-Stuyvesant

Authentic Jamaican patties, coco bread, and refreshing drinks

6 Postcards

Cocina Consuelo

Mexican restaurant · Hamilton Heights

Masa pancake, birria, mole negro, café de olla

33 Postcards

The Snail

American restaurant · Greenpoint

American bistro serving steak frites, burgers, and seafood

12 Postcards

San Sabino

Italian restaurant · West Village

Italian-American seafood with playful riffs on classics

32 Postcards