Pizza by Lucille’s

Pizza restaurant · Central Harlem

2

@infatuation

"This terrific slice spot is counter-service-only, but happens to specialize in crunchy-edged square pies you’ll want to share with friends over a few drinks. Happily, there’s a workaround. Their sister spot Lucille’s, a plant-filled coffee and cocktail bar with a solid all-day menu, is located just two doors down. And they really don’t mind if you bring your pizza over. Order the broccoli rabe and sweet sausage or the pepperoni cup-packed grandma square pie to-go, then head down the block for martinis, rum punch, and craft beers. And if for some reason you aren’t in the mood for pizza, the kale caesar salad and baby back ribs on Lucille’s dinner menu are both good choices. Food Rundown Roni Grandma Square Pie This square pie has one of the crispiest crusts around. All the better to hold the sweet, garlicky tomato sauce and layer of cheese covered from edge to edge with chewy little roni cups. Broc-Rabe Sausage Square Pie When you want your pizza to feel less like your usual order and more like a fancy meal, order this crunchy square pie. A coating of creamy béchamel acts as the base for layers of soft mozzarella, slightly bitter broccoli rabe, and crumbled sweet Italian sausage. Make sure you’ve got a bottle of red waiting at home." - The Curious Uptowner

Pizza by Lucille’s - Review - Harlem - New York - The Infatuation
Pizza By Lucille's

26c Macombs Pl, New York, NY 10039 Get directions

pizzabylucilles.com

2 Postcards

See full details

More Places For You

Ribalta

Italian restaurant · Greenwich Village

Dive into a vibrant haven of authentic Neapolitan pizza and Italian bites, where the delightful dough and lively atmosphere steal the show.

9 Postcards

4 Charles Prime Rib

Steak house · West Village

At Brendan Sodikoff’s 4 Charles, snag an elusive reservation and indulge in a vintage-styled steakhouse where the Wagyu burger reigns supreme.

26 Postcards

Death & Co East Village

Cocktail bar · East Village

Step into a dimly lit cocktail lounge where bow-tied bartenders whip up expertly crafted drinks, creating a vibrant, speakeasy vibe perfect for intimate gatherings.

22 Postcards

Tico's Cafetería

Cuban restaurant · Bushwick

1 Postcard

Alibi

Bar · Fort Greene

Old-school, cash-only dive bar drawing locals & students with cheap drinks, jukebox & pool table.

2 Postcards

Defonte's Sandwich Shop

Sandwich shop · Red Hook

This historic Red Hook sandwich shop has been crafting legendary heros, like their crispy fried eggplant and rich chicken parmesan, since the 1920s.

13 Postcards

Reichenbach Hall

German restaurant · Midtown West

Hearty German eats & fine beers are served in a casual, Bavarian publike setting.

3 Postcards

Brennan & Carr

Sandwich shop · Sheepshead Bay

This iconic 1930s restaurant is known for its irresistible hot roast beef sandwiches, charming ambiance, and attentive service that feels like a blast from the past.

14 Postcards

Chalong Southern Thai

Thai restaurant · Midtown West

This trendy Thai eatery offers a cozy vibe with mouthwatering Southern dishes, fresh seafood, and creative cocktails that promise an unforgettable meal.

12 Postcards

Stonewall National Monument Visitor Center

History museum · West Village

"THE STONEWALL NATIONAL MONUMENT VISITOR CENTER, IS UNWAVERING IN OUR EFFORT TO PROTECT AND PRESERVE THE STONEWALL LEGACY AND HISTORY. WE HONOR THE BRAVE PIONEERS, ESPECIALLY TRANSGENDER AND GENDER-NONCONFORMING INDIVIDUALS, WHO LED THE STONEWALL REBELLION."

2 Postcards