Gage & Tollner

American restaurant · Downtown Brooklyn

59

@infatuation

The Oldest Restaurants & Bars In NYC

"This Downtown Brooklyn steakhouse is one of NYC’s first, and yet it’s also a relative newcomer—it's current incarnation was reborn in 2021. The 19th-century Gage & Tollner closed in 2004, after which the beautiful landmarked building enjoyed a rumspringa as a TGI Friday’s and an Arby’s. Appropriately, our favorite dish here these days is a throwback: the baked alaska." - bryan kim, molly fitzpatrick, willa moore, will hartman, sonal shah

https://www.theinfatuation.com/new-york/guides/oldest-restaurants-bars-nyc

372 Fulton St 2nd Floor, Brooklyn, NY 11201 Get directions

gageandtollner.com
@gage.and.tollner

59 Postcards

Reserve
See full details

More Places For You

Hide Rooftop

Cocktail bar · Financial District

Nestled atop the Artezen Hotel in FiDi, Hide Rooftop blends chic elegance with a cozy vibe, offering delectable cocktails and stunning city views—perfect for unwinding after a long day.

2 Postcards

Drai's Supper Club New York

Fine dining restaurant · West Village

Drai's Supper Club in the West Village fuses French elegance with a vibrant, jazzy atmosphere, serving mouthwatering dishes like caviar pasta and killer steak.

2 Postcards

HYDERABADI ZAIQA

Indian restaurant · Midtown East

Hyderabadi Zaiqa serves up bold, authentic Hyderabadi flavors with standout biryanis, spicy curries, and hearty desserts in a modern, spacious setting.

3 Postcards

Hani’s bakery + café

Bakery · East Village

Hani’s in the East Village whips up elevated American classics—think gooey cinnamon buns, rich honey cake, and inventive seasonal pastries—in a cozy, chic spot.

11 Postcards

Chelsea Living Room

Restaurant · Chelsea

Chelsea Living Room is a swanky Chelsea bistro with cozy booths, creative cocktails, and indulgent small plates setting a chic, lively vibe.

4 Postcards

Sweet Afton

Bar · Astoria

Sweet Afton is Astoria's stylish Irish pub, featuring a cozy vibe with exposed brick, a heated garden patio, and a delicious menu of hearty bites and craft cocktails.

7 Postcards

Nathan's Famous

Hot dog restaurant · Coney Island

Nathan’s Famous at Coney Island serves up legendary all-beef hot dogs and crispy fries in a nostalgic, bustling boardwalk setting since 1916.

16 Postcards

Al Coro

Italian restaurant · Chelsea

Al Coro transforms classic Italian fare with modern twists, fresh pasta menus, live jazz, and top-notch service in Chelsea’s sleek, intimate space.

23 Postcards

Porchlight

Cocktail bar · Chelsea

Danny Meyer’s spacious Chelsea bar Porchlight serves Southern-inspired cocktails and snacks in a laid-back spot perfect for groups and game nights.

20 Postcards

Kings County Brewers Collective

Brewery · Bushwick

Nestled in Bushwick, Kings County Brewers Collective brews its own quirky, delicious craft beers in a spacious, lively taproom where dogs and outside snacks are welcome.

11 Postcards