"What It Is: A Chicago-style deep dish pizza place in Soho Perfect For: Casual Weeknight Dinner Emmett’s is a Chicago-style deep dish place, and, since we’re working on a ranking of the best pizza in NYC, we thought it was time to check it out. Although before consuming deep dish here, we had a hot dog, an Italian sausage, and a thin-crust pizza covered in ranch. And the thin crust pizza was probably the best thing we ate. As for the deep dish, the crust itself wasn’t anything special (sort of like a stale shortbread cookie), but we’d eat it again if it were put in front of us. Will it make our final pizza list? Probably not, but it’s hard to be upset with a large serving of melted cheese. The Verdict: The closest you’ll find to Chicago-style pizza in NYC." - hannah albertine, bryan kim, katherine lewin, hillary reinsberg, chris stang, matt tervooren