"This isn't our favorite lobster roll in New York City, but it is, definitively, our favorite lobster roll served in the very same building as the Stephen Sondheim Theatre. On its own, the Classic Lobster Roll is neither particularly good nor bad, but combined with the culinary cheat code that is Burger & Lobster's creamy lemon and garlic butter, it's delicious. This sandwich costs $30—arguably a steal, considering a) it's a lobster roll and b) you're basically in Times Square—and comes with fries, which you should liberally dip in that butter. Burger & Lobster has plenty of room for groups and is open till 11pm on weekends and 10pm otherwise." - neha talreja, bryan kim, hannah albertine, sonal shah, will hartman, molly fitzpatrick
Molly Fitzpatrick
