Ortobello's

Italian restaurant · Borough Park

5

@infatuation

"Of all the places on this list, Ortobello's in Mapleton is the one we want to scream about from the rooftops. And then, once we've finished screaming, we want to bring everyone here for a big birthday dinner, or just a regular Sunday night. Ortobello’s, which opened in 1964, quietly serves some of the best red-sauce Italian food in the city. It’s run by Andy, whose father ran it before him, and who ambles around the dining room in a backwards baseball cap, refilling wine and thanking people for being here. You don't hear about this place too often, but that's all the more reason to come, whenever you need to be warmed from the inside out by way of cheese. If they have vodka chicken parm on special, get it." - willa moore, will hartman, sonal shah, neha talreja

NYC's Greatest Old-School Italian Restaurants, From Oldest To Newest

6401 Bay Pkwy, Brooklyn, NY 11204 Get directions

@ortobellorestaurant

5 Postcards

See full details

More Places For You

Bar Centrale

Bar · Midtown West

Exclusive bar/lounge in a converted apartment that often plays host to Broadway stars post-show.

6 Postcards

Little Ruby's SoHo

Restaurant · Nolita

This charming Australian café draws in a stylish crowd with its delightful breakfast offerings, including standout burgers and a cozy outdoor dining vibe.

18 Postcards

Mercado Little Spain

Food court · Chelsea

Mercado Little Spain is a lively Spanish market at Hudson Yards, offering a delightful mix of authentic tapas, paella, and festive vibes that whisk you away to Spain.

56 Postcards

Norman Ave Design

Marble contractor · Williamsburg

"We specialize in all Marble, Quartz & Granite Fabrication & Installation. We serve the NY Metro area. All projects welcome"

1 Postcard

Luke's Lobster Brooklyn Bridge Park

Seafood restaurant · DUMBO

Seafood restaurant serving Maine-style lobster rolls with toasted buns, plus clam chowder.

3 Postcards

Rubirosa

Pizza restaurant · Nolita

Rubirosa is your go-to spot for deliciously reinvented Italian-American eats and thin-crust pizzas, all served in a cozy, inviting space.

35 Postcards

sushi AMANE

Sushi restaurant · Midtown East

Nestled in a cozy basement, this intimate 8-seat omakase counter at Mifune serves meticulously crafted, top-notch sushi that dazzles the palate.

10 Postcards

Bowery Poetry Club

Arts organization · NoHo

Bowery Poetry Club blends modern elegance with intimate vibes, offering a lively lineup of poetry, music, and eclectic performances in a cozy space.

2 Postcards

Arlo Williamsburg

Hotel · Williamsburg

This polished hotel boasts chic rooms and suites with stunning balcony views, three bars, a vibrant rooftop pool, and is perfectly placed among trendy eateries.

12 Postcards

Corner Bar

Restaurant · Chinatown

Tucked away near Chinatown, this cozy bar and restaurant is renowned for its flawless seafood, commendable service, and inviting ambiance, making it a must-visit.

25 Postcards