3

Settle Down Tavern

American restaurant · First Settlement ·

Settle Down Tavern

American restaurant · First Settlement ·
@postcardnews
22,027 Postcards · 1,950 Cities

Downtown “Smash Burger Headquarters” turns out the Good Idea Double using Wisconsin beef. Frequently praised by local food writers and Destination Madison; late‑night smash specials keep it lively.

https://www.settledownmadison.com/
Best Burgers in Madison (2025)
View this post on Instagram

Information

Smash burgers, decadent sandwiches, and fries with a bar

smash burger
cheese curds
good idea burger
cocktails
great service
friendly staff
cheese puppies
ghost fries
Google Rating
4.5 (548)
Yelp Rating
4.4
Featured in Eater
Featured in

117 S Pinckney St, Madison, WI 53703 Get directions

$20–30

Order delivery
See Menu
Restroom
Accepts reservations
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Cozy
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by Eater - Lists + Maps
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
See full details

3

Information

Smash burgers, decadent sandwiches, and fries with a bar

smash burger
cheese curds
good idea burger
cocktails
great service
friendly staff
cheese puppies
ghost fries
Google Rating
4.5 (548)
Yelp Rating
4.4
Featured in Eater
Featured in

117 S Pinckney St, Madison, WI 53703 Get directions

$20–30

Order delivery
See Menu
Restroom
Accepts reservations
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Cozy
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by Eater - Lists + Maps
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
Settle Down Tavern by null
See full details

More Places For You

Sardine

Bistro · The Isthmus

French-inspired bistro with creative fare, lake views & lively bar

7 Postcards

Tornado Steak House

Steak house · Downtown

Classic steakhouse with traditional chops, seafood & cocktails

2 Postcards

The James

Student housing center · State-Langdon

Furnished apartments, fitness center, academic success center

0 Postcards

Madison Sourdough

Bakery · The Isthmus

Artisanal bakery offering French pastries, gourmet breakfast & lunch

2 Postcards

Los Atlantes Restaurant & Bakery

Mexican restaurant · Near West Side

Authentic Mexican bakery & restaurant serving pozole, barbacoa

1 Postcard

Cadre Restaurant

French restaurant · Regent

French-inspired dishes, local ingredients, select wine, patio dining

1 Postcard

Leopold's Books Bar Caffè

Coffee shop · South Campus

Bookstore cafe with literary cocktails, coffee, pastries & patio

4 Postcards

Culver’s

American restaurant · Hawthorne

Frozen custard, burgers made with Midwest beef & dairy.

1 Postcard

Marigold Kitchen

Cafe · First Settlement

Creative breakfast & lunch fare with outdoor seating

6 Postcards

Mint Mark

New American restaurant · Marquette

Produce-forward small plates, creative pastas, and a sharp cocktail program

12 Postcards