Jihye B.
Yelp
A solid 4.5 with (or, in spite of?) crazy social media hype!
This was my second time attempting to get inside this currently very viral matcha tea house. There was a long wait despite it being so close to closing time last time. This time, the wait was not quite as long as it was a random Tuesday afternoon. They do provide an umbrella to protect you from the sun while you wait-- a lovely touch.
The menu is relatively simple. You could get "Matcha Americano" - regular matcha, or a "Matcha Latte" - milk added. It was a little jarring to see that there was this pomp and ceremony around the matcha prep but they do not offer different blends or mixed beverages. There's also ice cream and some baked goods available.
It is definitely interesting to see the big vats of water with the long stick of charcoal thrown in, how the water gets put in this heated urn, the methodical uniformity in which the matcha is prepped by the workers donning apron and little bandana. And the portion of matcha you get per drink feels like a generous amount for the price, which is not crazy expensive for a matcha drink in NYC. There is quite a bit of bottleneck because of this prep, though. I loved standing around smelling the floral and fragrant matcha, but it did take a while for the line to move.
I got the Matcha Americano, iced and unsweetened. I also got the matcha Basque cheesecake and my friend got two scoops of ice cream, the hojicha and the matcha. The ice cream did start turning into a puddle by the time we got it because it was scooped out way before it was our turn for our matcha to be prepared. The cheesecake was absolutely forgettable and should be skipped altogether. The ice cream was better than expected, especially the hojicha flavor whose nuttiness really punctuated the strongly floral and bright flavor of the matcha drinks. The matcha drinks were also excellent, blended very well and with really balanced flavor. I did not regret my decision to get it unsweetened because the matcha itself felt light, not bitter at all, though the flavor was strong.
Though there is seating inside the shop, there's not a lot of space and your ability to snag a seat depended on chance. There was also a "tasting room" corner on the basement level, but I wasn't sure what it was being used for, as there was no option of different blends being offered on the regular menu. I think the overcrowding might be alleviated if they kept separate lines for dine-in vs take-out, but that does take a lot of work. Overall, I was pleasantly surprised by the tasty matcha at 12 Matcha and would return again.