Calder S.
Yelp
I have mixed feelings about Bar Del Monte. I like what they are trying to do and I like the service-included model, but I don't think they are operating at the top of their game or that they are worth the trip.
Their website menu leaves a lot to be desired. Unlike the IRL menu, it doesn't include any dish descriptions and it doesn't include any prices. For a restaurant that prides itself on service-included pricing, not being price transparent on the website is a let down. Both the website and IRL menus don't do a good job of indicating which dishes are appetizers vs entrees. It turns out that the only entrees are pizzas, which was not what I expected. I thought some of the dishes that turned out to just be apps would be entrees, or some of the specials (unlisted online) would also be entrees. Nope. I thought they would have some pasta dishes or something, or the grilled fish of the day would be an entree (mentioned online but absent IRL).
I visited on a Sunday at 5 PM right when they opened with a party of four. The restaurant is very small, with only roughly 4 four-tops, 7 two-tops, and 5 seats at the bar. It looks like they maybe have some room to expand in the front and back. We were the 5th group of four, so were initially turned away, until they combined two of the two-tops for us. So, if you arrive with a group, get there early or be prepared to wait. In contrast, two-tops were easy to get. I did notice a few two-tops squeeze in a third person.
Service was adequate. It was not particularly helpful or friendly. It took a long time for food to come out.
We had a selection of share plates: fritto (fried veggies, $19), arrosticini (five lamb skewers, $17), artichoke salad ($21), lamb liver pate ($21), clam pizza (12", 6 slices, $27). Quality was good but portions were small. I don't recommend ordering like we did; better to get one pizza per person and then supplement with small plates or dessert if desired. When we split these all four ways, I didn't really get enough of any dish to appreciate it. The fritto had a very nice, light, crunchy tempura fry. Lamb skewers were also tasty. Pate was pate. Salad was pretty bland. Clam pizza was fine but not clammy enough. Pate was served with three pieces of bread even though we were a four-top, so we asked for more (free).
We also had some wine ($10-$15), beer ($7), and negronis ($14). The beer is only 240ml (~8 oz) which is less than a can (12oz) and a proper pint (16oz). This feels a big disingenuous. IMO 12oz is the minimum amount any restaurant should be serving for beer, with a pint the actual proper serving size.
Some of us were still hungry but no one wanted to order more at Bar Del Monte. We had heard great things about the restaurant but were unanimously unimpressed.
I'm also disappointed that prices didn't include tax. If you include service, you might as well include tax.
I found the menu prices a little high but I kept reminding myself that prices included service. I did some math afterwards and I think the prices are reasonable for what we got.