Barnyard Cheese Shop

Cheese shop · East Village

Barnyard Cheese Shop

Cheese shop · East Village

168 Avenue B, New York, NY 10009

Highlights

Classic cheesemonger also carrying a variety of charcuterie, salads, soups, sides & sandwiches.

168 Avenue B, New York, NY 10009 Get directions

barnyardcheese.com

@barnyardcheese

$ · Menu

@infatuation

"Re-opened after two years, just in time for all of your holiday charcuterie board needs, Barnyard Cheese is an East Village cheese and meats shop. They also make sandwiches, including one called the Figgy Piggy. It’s a sister business to Brix Wine Shop, making this little corner on Avenue B the perfect “I forgot to pick something up for that holiday party” destination." - Will Hartman, Willa Moore

NYC’s New Restaurant Openings - New York - The Infatuation

View Postcard for Barnyard Cheese Shop

@eater

"Barnyard Cheese Shop has returned to the East Village, known for its sandwiches." - Emma Orlow

NYC New Restaurant Openings, January 2024 - Eater NY

View Postcard for Barnyard Cheese Shop

Todd Fellerman

Google

Absolutely love this place! So so happy it came back after being closed. They have the best sandwiches and salads -- always delicious and fresh. And they also have an awesome cheese selection & awesome yummy, freshly made side dishes too. Barnyard love 🎊❤️ My personal favorites are: the Popeye salad (with grilled chicken) and The Greatest American sandwich. Both are divine 👅

Julia S

Google

YUM!! These sandwiches were so good! Would reccomend getting the chicken warm sandwich on different bread because the ciabatta (?) was way too thick. Overall loved everything.

Eric Sanchez

Google

I go here for the BLT's on toasted sourdough w/ herbal mayo. There so good! They also have an interesting assortment of sandwiches, cheeses, chips & snacks. And if you call ahead your sandwiches will be ready to go when you get there.

Brittany Sullivan

Google

My favorite sandwich place in the East Village! I love the “body builder” sandwich and for anyone who does eat meat, my advice is to add prosciutto. The team at Barnyard Cheese is so nice and you really can’t go wrong with anything you order.

Sandy Rodriguez

Google

Probably the best sandwich I've had in New York - the Mexican Cuban. Employees are very nice. Only downside is that it can take quite some time during the lunch rush, so maybe call ahead or it can take a while.

Simon of Elmet

Google

Sounds crazy but I ate the best BLT sandwich I have ever had at the Barnyard Cheese shop. Devoured it. Demolished it.

Christopher Cornish

Google

Cheese, sandwiches, salads - all select and well made. Their meatballs have become a staple for me. Very nice, friendly staff. Some seating, but limited. Lots of "odds and ends" that can be fun to poke around about. a great little neighborhood store in an area with limited grocery options.

Evan Crew

Google

Extremely rude. The sandwiches are incredible, but the woman at the cashier stand was downright nasty and mean to me, for no reason. I literally cried on my way home with my sandwich. You really shouldn't treat your customers like that. I don't care how good the food is, I don't make a habit of patronizing places that are abusive to their customers. So I write this to warn prospective sandwich eaters. Steer clear. Go to Maiden Lane instead.

Ryan C.

Yelp

Tasty. Chips good too they actually taste like truffle. Very good gonna go back today

Joe L.

Yelp

Everything about this place is amazing. The food is excellent! Beatrice the owner, is a gem. So happy they reopened

Terry T.

Yelp

Great place for salads. And sandwiches for lunching in ytomol s sq park the neighborhood missed them w hen they wereclosed for a few months. The Mexican Cuban isn't even close to Cuban sandwich but it's good

@infatuation

NYC’s New Restaurant Openings - New York - The Infatuation

View Postcard for Barnyard Cheese Shop

@eater

"Barnyard Cheese Shop has returned to the East Village, known for its sandwiches." - Emma Orlow

NYC New Restaurant Openings, January 2024 - Eater NY

View Postcard for Barnyard Cheese Shop

Todd Fellerman

Google

Julia S

Google

YUM!! These sandwiches were so good! Would reccomend getting the chicken warm sandwich on different bread because the ciabatta (?) was way too thick. Overall loved everything.

Eric Sanchez

Google

Brittany Sullivan

Google

Sandy Rodriguez

Google

Simon of Elmet

Google

Sounds crazy but I ate the best BLT sandwich I have ever had at the Barnyard Cheese shop. Devoured it. Demolished it.

Christopher Cornish

Google

Evan Crew

Google

Ryan C.

Yelp

Tasty. Chips good too they actually taste like truffle. Very good gonna go back today

Joe L.

Yelp

Everything about this place is amazing. The food is excellent! Beatrice the owner, is a gem. So happy they reopened

Terry T.

Yelp

Barnyard Cheese Shop

Photos

Highlights

Postcards

You might also like