Brandon Fry
Google
By good fortune I was able to find a single open seat at the bar on the restaurant's second day open, so I figured I had to try it out and see if it was worth the local hype. I'm generally an enjoyer of Starr restaurants, recognizing that they don't usually push the envelope and play things pretty safe, while maybe being a touch overpriced for the quality of food. With that said: Borromini absolutely smashed by expectations and I cannot wait to return.
The atmosphere and space is excellent, and I was frankly shocked at the scope and size of the staff and just how many people the place could accommodate. Despite being brand new, everything seemed meticulously operated and working at full steam in a crazy busy environment. The bartenders that took care of me were excellent, helping me with the menu and any questions I had, as well as being exceptionally personable and attentive. The "bar" itself is one of the most impressive looking collections of bottle's I've seen at a restaurant, spanning multiple different walls (even if some of it is just decorative). Otherwise, it's a warmly lit space with a blend of rustic and modern vibes but was quite comfortable, albeit a bit noisy.
I am a big fan of Negronis and was pleased that there is an entire section on the drink menu of Negroni variations. I got the Negroni biano, a white Negroni that was delightful. If I were tasting it blind I wouldn't have even known it was a variation to be honest, I'm impressed they nailed the flavors and kept it fresh without red vermouth or Campari.
The star of the show was undoubtedly the pasta. Although my picture may not do it justice, the amatriciana from the classics "Pasta Romana" menu was astonishingly good. Made with Bucatini, guanciale, pecorino, and tomatoes, it was so deep in flavor and perfect in every way despite being a "simple" and straightforward dish. I am very optimistic that if they can nail a classic and simpler pasta like this that all the other more elaborate pastas are also excellent. The portion was just right, it was hearty and substantial without needing to take any leftovers home. Right now for my money, I think this might be the best pasta in center city though I will have to return to try some of the other options. Folks dining near me also seemed to be enjoying their 100-layer lasagnas and other pastas, it all looked good.
I don't have anything critical to say all, to be honest. Perhaps each item costs a few bucks more than is ideal but it's in a beautiful space right at Rittenhouse square, it's just hard to beat. As far as I know, dinners are booked out for the whole month but don't hesitate to try for a spot at the bar on a weeknight.