Nalani R.
Yelp
We ended up in Buckbeard when our first choice ended up being pick up only. While I was craving a totally different kind of food, Buckbeard was a great "we ended up here instead" choice.
First, the positives: service was excellent and the serving size of the food was great. The lady behind the counter with dark curly hair who ended up as our cashier and main server was SO nice. It was never anything over the top but she was just friendly and helpful. I didn't see name tags on any of the staff so I didn't get her name, but she was great.
As far as the food went, we were not prepared for the amount of food we got! While one may think that the price point isn't on the cheap side, they do give you a good amount of food for the price. We were planning on getting a half rack of ribs with the tri-tip, pulled pork and sides that we ordered. They ran out of the ribs and that was a blessing in disguise for us because we boxed up around 60% of the food we ordered. The ribs would have been much too much.
I couldn't give 5 stars because I found the food itself underseasoned and the meats either under cooked or overcooked. The tri-tip we found underseasoned and undercooked. The fat and gristle were still hard and have not rendered out, it would also be better with more seasoning as it tasted bland. It was okay with the sauces they provided but good bbq meat should taste good on its own, with the sauce just extra.
The pulled pork was the tastier of the meat, specially since it came topped with bbq sauce already. We found the meat a bit over cooked tho, with the texture mushy instead of tender with good shreds.
The sausage had good texture but also underseasoned.
The wedge fries were the surprise best side. They look burnt because they're dark but they were perfectly cooked, crunchy on the outside, and well seasoned.
The Shhh Puppies are not our favorite. I was excited to see it because I fell in love with hush puppies in the East Coast and haven't found good ones here. The search continues as these stuffed hush puppies are very heavy, very grainy, and bland--which is surprising because it should be flavorful with the corn flour, cheese, and Jalapeño.
The cornbread was ok, large, very firm muffins of them. While the outside was a bit hard and toothsome, they tasted good and I'd probably order them again.
All in all, Buckbeard is a good place to go to if you live in the area. We will probably not go back because we found the cooking of the meat a bit uneven and the meats and Texas toast underseasoned. We could have just gotten a bad batch tho and the friendly service and good portions are still worth four stars.