Butter Smashburgers

Absolutely blown away by Butter Smashburgers! Hands down one of the best halal burger joints in NYC. The patties are perfectly smashed — crispy edges, juicy center, and that signature buttery flavor in every bite. I had the Bombay Butter and it was next-level — spicy, tangy, and packed with bold desi flavor. The fries were perfectly seasoned, and their Burnt Butter Caramel Shake? Unreal. The place has a cool vibe — casual, clean, and full of energy. Staff were super friendly and the service was quick. It’s rare to find a spot that nails flavor and quality and keeps it fully zabihah halal. Definitely coming back — this spot is a game changer!

Halal smash burger spot. Burger was pretty good, fries were OK, and juice was ok. Small seating area, nice atmosphere. Good prices.

I recently came across this place on social media and decided to try it as I always love a good burger. Overall the place and good is decent but nothing really special. It's not too expensive of a place but to be honest I think that 7th street a couple doors down blows this out of the water. The burger itself was very salty and dry and lacked any actual burger flavor. I will say though, they gave a hefty amount of pickles which really helped me finish the burger. The cheese fries were very good, well seasoned and well cooked. The place has a nice look to it but overall I would probably say this is a try once type of place.

Burgers were okay. Not the complete best but it was pretty good. Price for the combo was also reasonable. Included a drink and fries. Seats are very limited if you want stay in inside. Tried their single burger with fries. Fries were amazing as well.

If you're near NYU's campus and craving an unforgettable burger experience, Butter Smashburger is an absolute must-visit! The burgers here are simply outstanding—juicy, perfectly seasoned, and smashed to perfection with crispy edges that add a fantastic crunch. The flavor combinations are creative yet comforting, with fresh, quality ingredients that take every bite to the next level. The buns are soft and slightly toasted, holding everything together without overpowering the flavors. The next time I go I’ll try their hot chicken sandwich. The atmosphere is cozy and welcoming, but super small and no place to sit. However making it a great spot to grab a bite with friends or enjoy a solo meal. The service is quick, and the staff is friendly, adding to the overall great vibe of the place. Whether you're a local or just passing through, Butter Smashburger has quickly become my go-to spot for a satisfying meal. Highly recommend it for anyone near the area—five stars all the way!

Got a double smash burger and fries. Everything was very tasty! Good burger with a great sauce and nice crunchy fries

So yummy!!! I normally don't like pickles and specifically ask without, but I forgot this time. And the burger was still incredible! The pickles weren't pungent and watery which was great for a pickle hater like me. The bun was so nice an fluffy which is often rare for burger establishments since they focus more on the meat. Everything about the simple cheeseburger just paired so well with each other and made to order. The soft serve really blew it out the park in my opinion. I expected a quick dessert but I got a really quality cup. The vanilla flavoring just felt rich and light, the creaminess was so so smooth, the caramel was not too artificially sweet, and the crumbs on top just added a extra texture that brought this entire meal to a satisfying stop.

Halal burgers in NYC. Very tasty, only thing for me was, it was slightly too salty. Otherwise portion size was good, their peach ice tea was also very nice. However, there isn’t much seating in the restaurant because it’s a small place.

Review for the fried chicken sandwich and fries. A top-tier fried chicken sandwich, and near top-tier fries. The sandwich was a generous breast, perfectly cooked and sauced--slightly sweet with a hint of spice, neither dry nor wet, crisp breading and skin, flawless--and complemented by a slightly oversized potato bun that unlike most of its kind held shape and did NOT get soggy, while not sacrificing an ounce of flavor. Generously cut pickles, an excellent slaw relish with onions and carrots, and American cheese. Fries were perfectly salted and double-fried for peak crispiness. About the only complaint I have is one of my paper bag handles tore off, but that may well have been user error. Oh, and the woman at the counter addressed me by name and was extremely kind. I sit here on a bench at 6th Ave and Bedford in 25-degree weather, wholly content. Thank you, Butter, and see you soon.

Butter Smashburgers is a bit of a mixed bag for me. The interior is kinda unique and nice (when they have emptied the trash recently, that is). The burger itself was quite good, but the cheese fries were kind of terrible. The fries themselves are nothing special, and the cheese is just that nasty cheep nacho cheese goo you get on chips at a crappy movie theater. The burger is definitely something worth trying, but I can't recommend the fries.

Butter Smashburgers came highly recommended by a friend who's no stranger to the NYU area, so naturally, I had to give it a try. I strolled in with high hopes, ready for a burger experience. I went for the double cheeseburger with everything on it. The first bite revealed a perfectly cooked patty nestled in a soft, warm bun that practically gave me a hug. I wanted to like it and I usually appreciate a well-seasoned burger, but this one was a little too over-seasoned for me. Also, I'm all for pickles, but this burger seemed to be trying to break a pickle world record. A little less would've gone a long way. On the bright side, the service was on point! The cashier was friendly, and the whole place was spotless and well lit. The outdoor seating was a nice touch, too--great for people-watching while you dive into burger goodness.

Probably the best halal chicken burger I've had in nyc. I got the buffalo chicken burger which was one of their new monthly flavors. It tasted like I was eating a buffalo chicken wing, and I mean that in the best way possible. Meat very tender as well while still having that crunch you want from a chicken burger. My husband got the beef smash burger and ranked it as top 2 smash burgers he's had in the city. The fries were pretty standard, nothing to complain about. There's not much seating but most people take their food to go anyways so you can usually grab a seat. Marking as my go to spot for chicken burgers

Solid Smashburger spot! I thought their double cheeseburger was a little salty and could use more sauce but it was still delicious. Their fried chicken sandwich was also amazing - juicy on the inside and crispy on the outside. It also comes with this ranch like sauce which we asked for extra on our cheese fries - a must do. The fries were thin and crispy and the melted cheese actually tasted like real cheese. The space is small with a few bar counter stools and tables on the sidewalk. If you don't like it or are craving another burger, 7th street burger is literally 3 doors down so it's a win win regardless.

Make way for a new a smashburger location and this one brings finesse from their packaging to the overall vibe/decor of the space on MacDougal Street. I ordered a classic cheeseburger which includes their own sauce, pickles, and grilled onions. My only critique is that the bun is too soft which absorbs the sauce and patty so if you order and take to go, you might run the risk of soggy buns and getting cold. So I would recommend eating it at the moment which is the best option. The fries were your classic crispy one that pairs perfectly with the burger. The attention to detail on packaging from the to-go bag, burger box, and fries cup was top tier because it can have its own photoshoot. The location stands out on MacDougal Street since it's their take on a classic burger joint but futuristic with white bright lights, indoor metal chairs. They do have outdoor seating as well. Plus a huge mirror to take pictures with your friends or by yourself with your stylish to-go bag order. The cashier was super kind and attentive when placing my order since it was quite busy when I arrived with orders being placed and ready to be picked up. They call out your name for the order so be ready to pick up so you can enjoy it still warm and fresh. I would recommend adding this to your list of smashburgers to try in Manhattan. Or come over as a late night bite while hanging out in the West 4th area

Simple but very delicious smashburgers here, and well priced for nyc standards (a single burger was $7 all in). All components are great - the meat is delicious, potato bun, melty american, pickle, onion, and their sauce. A very nice and quick burger

Butter may have 7th Street beat for me... but it might just be the ice cream. The people working here are efficient and kind. Their smashburger has a pillowy bun and their fries are perfectly crispy. I am a huge soft serve fan and I love being able to get chocolate syrup on top! The only thing that would make it better would be sprinkles.

I thought it was going to be too buttery due to the name however it was not the case. Very solid burger, nice crisp and well seasoned, and not drenched in sauce. Surprisingly liked this over 7th street burger next door. Very clean space, and the workers there were very nice and inviting.

Not gonna lie best burger I've had I've tried multiple smash burgers from numerous locations n this place was the best it's pretty popular in the area surprised it took me so long to find it the menu is very small less than 10 items I believe but with a burger like that you don't need to sell much more.

I am a huge fan of smashburgers so I had to try Butter as soon as I heard it was opening. A friend checked it out with me around 9pm since it's open pretty late which is a plus. The line was long but went by pretty quickly so we didn't have to wait too long for our food. I got the double smash burger and the caramel soft serve. The burger was pretty good especially the bun and meat flavor. I will say it was saltier than I would like but overall it was one of the better smash burgers I have had in the city. However the soft serve was my favorite and I highly recommend getting it along with the burger. The ice cream is very creamy and a perfect sweetness. This might be my new go to fast smash burger joint.

incredible halal smashburgers, highly recommend. everything on the menu is under $10! there are only four or five seats at a counter so it's not gonna be great for a big group. but take it to go and eat at the park!

After perusing tik Tok and instagram at hours length, I kept seeing this smash burger place and as a smash burger aficionado, I was immediately intrigued. I usually routine this area often as many food establishments are up and down Macdougal, the area is one of my personal favorites. I stopped by on a friday afternoon and ordered the smashburger with fries. The stylization of the restaurant is cute, it gives a retro diner vibe, and the minimalist menu is something expected at any of these fast causal burger chains. It looks like a more upscale version of 7th street burger. 7th street happens to be down the block- literally. The service is fast and they have a bar you can sit at inside and a few tables outside. The burger itself was flat. The bun was too thick and soft and the patty itself was greasy, and lacking flavor and bite. I realized maybe the single patty was too small and I should have opted for a double, but usually I like to try the single at first to get an impression of the meat, quality, and overall taste. Generally these types of burgers are greasy and heavy but thats the entire point, here the burger just tasted like grease. It almost felt too light and not satiating at all. The fries were just okay, very salty and nothing special or impressive. This place is an easy miss in my book, but a good alternative for someone seeking a halal option in the smashburger market. Overall the food was abysmal.

Great smashburger and chicken sandwich here served out of a a narrow restaurant in the village. Seating is tight, one bar with a few seats inside and one communal-ish table outside.

A rainy summer night. I'm on the prowl for a good time but first, I got a hunger to fix. I seen this place in passing before but finally decided to stop in. The staff is small but a powerhouse. If I place my order at 8, it was hot, fresh and ready by 8:05. Definitely arrived at a good time. I had to take the meal to go as the indoor seating is a simple counter for 4, which can be become cramped at high volume. And the outdoor is roughly 2 intimate size tables. The rain changed that plan so took it to the car and enjoyed my meal, drive thru style. Not pictured in the images is the peach iced tea. It was quite small. A few swigs and it's done. The cup was the same size that is used for ice cream. That would've made for a more satisfying selection. 3/5 for the size and the fact that it tasted like regular peach Snapple.

One of the best smash burgers I've ever had. Meat is tender and not hard to break, bun is incredibly soft like a pillow, and sauce is unique; not a Big Mac copycat. Area is small and service was not great nor awful. Music was really good. Would come back

This is a good bones smashburger that needs more sauce to be taken over the top; the ratio of meat to sauce is distinctly off. (How does a single patty get the same amount of sauce as a double patty burger?) The very yellow cheese sauce served over the fries is nothing special and only serves to ruin the tasty crispy fries by making them soggy, so Don't order the cheese fries, get them plain! In this case, less is more. The chicken sandwich was juicy and served with nice toppings on a soft bun, but the very crispy crust had a noticeably burnt flavor that hampered enjoyment. Service was quick and friendly. The space itself was open and clean, and you could clearly see behind the counter all the cooking activity, (including the diligently measured stingy little circles of sauce application from the squeeze bottle applied on every bun). Once you get your food, you have a couple of limited seating options from the four bar stools at the side counter to eat, to the handful of patio tables located outside. Unfortunately, there is no bathroom for customers, so keep that in mind.

Wish this was closer to where I lived. Small shop but nice and clean, kind of a retro vibe. Simple menu. Prices are great. They get it to you quickly. Plus, best of all, the burger is great. One of my favorites in the city. Size, grease level, all of that is just right. And they don't rest on their laurels with the fries either, those are good too.

Have been here twice so far and love it! The menu is nice and simple, burgers taste great and the price is on point!

Smash burgers seem to be raining everywhere and people are loving it. Located on MacDougal Street, Butter Smash Burger has been open for a month and business especially in the evenings is booming. Angela, the lady who took my order, said that last weekend was a bonanza. The menu is simple and everything is under $10. Just what is appealing to me. I had a single cheeseburger with fries and paid $10 & change. Five bar stools which seem quite uncomfortable line the table top. Is this deliberate? No lingering here? There are three line cooks and being a Monday there were a few people present. The interior is smallish and bright. No restrooms as this is essentially a grab and go or eat and go place. Music always makes the meal enjoyable for me and with "Abracadabra (Steve Miller Band) and "Another One Bites the Dust" (Queen) playing my lunch was appetizing. However with 7th Street Burger on the same block and a few doors down BSM will face tough competition. I hope it succeeds.

Great smashburger, patties are nice and crispy. Fries are excellent. Peach iced tea was good. Soft serve was on the icey side and not as creamy though. Would be back when in the area.

BEST SMASHBURGERS IN NYC NYC has an excessive supply of smashburger joints, its almost impossible to try them all. Don't bother, butter smashburgers trumps every spot. Who ever owns this is obviously a foodie who understands what truly makes a well rounded smash burger. The burgers have a perfect salt, fat and acidic level. Most spots will serve you salty or greasy beef, the search is finally over. The menu is simple. The other main option being a chicken sandwhich. THE BEST CHICKEN SANDWHICH IN NYC. Crispy, juicy, and flavorful What are the chances you can get an amazing chicken sandwich and burger at the same spot? (it's rare!!!) My experience at butter has made me only wishing the owner never ending success!!!!!

Cheeseburger. VERY GOOD. A Smash Burger which didn't disappoint. Tastes GOOD with nothing more to say. RECOMMEND.

I went to Butter with a friend we wanted to check it out and its a cute, clean venue, small but perfect it has what you want in a Smash burger, onions, cheese and even the bun is delicious. The fried chicken, fresh white meat yummy sandwich, the french fries with or without cheese awesome and to complete the order the creamy soft serve with sprinkled graham crackers makes your day!! I recommend Butter fast, simple, tasty and the price is right.!! We will be back with a smile. Hana XOX

Quick service! Small space but there's seating but it's also so close to washington square park you can eat your burger there. I got the single smash burger and the sauce and pickles were great on it. If you're a smash burger fan this place is great and only $6! Also they give you a good amount of napkins in the bag which is great because I'm quite messy haha

straight forward menu similar to 7th Street. solid smash burgers priced decently. it's a small restaurant but offer seatings.

Very comparable to 7th Street Burger, maybe less greasier but overall it tastes almost the same comparing this to 7th Street Burger, Gotham Burger and Hamburger America. Perfectly located on a street where the young crowd likes to frequent bars and clubs and have a good time and then have a late night meal. It's definitely a quick service restaurant to visit and come back again for more.