Cait's Key Lime

Bakery · Downtown Brooklyn

Cait's Key Lime

Bakery · Downtown Brooklyn

1

Willoughby Street & Jay Street, Brooklyn, NY 11201

Photos

Cait's Key Lime by null
Cait's Key Lime by Britt Lam
Cait's Key Lime by null
Cait's Key Lime by null
Cait's Key Lime by null
Cait's Key Lime by null
Cait's Key Lime by null
Cait's Key Lime by null
Cait's Key Lime by null
Cait's Key Lime by null
Cait's Key Lime by null
Cait's Key Lime by null
Cait's Key Lime by null
Cait's Key Lime by null
Cait's Key Lime by null
Cait's Key Lime by null

Highlights

Featured in The Infatuation
Placeholder
Placeholder

Willoughby Street & Jay Street, Brooklyn, NY 11201 Get directions

caitskeylime.com
@caitskeylime

Information

Static Map

Willoughby Street & Jay Street, Brooklyn, NY 11201 Get directions

caitskeylime.com
@caitskeylime

Features

takeout
delivery

Last updated

Mar 5, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@infatuation

"The next time you find yourself at a rooftop barbecue or a park hang, bring a key lime pie. When everyone else unveils their store-bought guac and chips or six-pack of canned wine, you’ll be the hero, especially if the pie is from Cait’s Key Lime. These pies are made to order and come in three sizes, Goldilocks-style. The filling is smooth and pudding-like, with an ideal combination of tartness and sweetness, and each pie is topped with a generous layer of whipped cream and zest. There’s no physical storefront, but you can order the larger sizes online for pickup or delivery, or find mini pies at Sweet Chick locations around town. photo credit: Britt Lam" - Britt Lam

Cait’s Key Lime - Review - Brooklyn - New York - The Infatuation
View Postcard for Cait's Key Lime

Chelsea Durrant

Google
The absolute best key lime pie I’ve had in years. It is on the richer side so recommend if you’re looking for something summery and decadent. Cait is also very sweet and easy to coordinate with

Yvonne W

Google
Best key lime pie! I’ve ordered this multiple times and it never disappoints. Perfect lime taste and the cream is delicious. I usually order an extra one just for myself so I don’t need to share. My mom’s diabetic but can have the pie since it’s not too sweet. Also comes with a gluten-free pie crust option which is perfect for my bf. And Cait is amazing!! So easy to communicate with and always accommodating. 💗

Catherine Newell-Hanson

Google
The best key lime pie I have ever had. Maybe actually the best pie I have ever had, seriously. I dream about this pie! We got them in mini size for an event and they were a hit! The crust is the perfect texture, and the filling is the perfect balance of sweet and tart. You can tell the ingredients are super fresh and carefully sourced, nothing tastes artificial or overly sweet. Truly a Queen amongst desserts. NOTE: this is an online biz, so order from the site and arrange delivery :)

Zoe van der Grinten

Google
Seriously one of my FAVORITE desserts in all the land! It’s the perfect balance of a zingy, fresh and creamy filling with a light and not-too-sweet whipped topping and buttery, salty crust. Cait’s Key Lime pies have been the star of most holidays and many dinners for our family (bonus points my husband is gluten free and the gluten free version is one of those very rare just as good as the gluten version) NOTE: it is an online business so follow the insta (@caitskeylime) for most up to date info. Plz do yourself a favor and order the best key lime pie in NYC!

George Xue

Google
Cait’s is simply the best. The ratio of cream to the rest of the pie is perfect and the flavor is without a doubt the most delicious I’ve ever had. If you haven’t tried her pie, you’re missing out!!

Brionna Rich

Google
Easily the best Key lime pie I have ever tasted. Ended up buying my coworker one and she loved it as well. I love when Cait does pop ups in my city. And if I can’t make it, I always spread the word. ❤️❤️❤️❤️

Sabrina Rodriguez

Google
These are worth the hype. If I could score one of these for every loved one’s birthday (key lime lover or not) I really would. My only warning is to not try it until you’re ready to be consumed by thoughts of this pie for the rest of your life. I wish I was kidding. My only side note is that they were easier to procure. I’m a dunce when it comes to remembering to pre order or plan out when I’ll next want/need a pie. If it were up to me I’d be part of a subscription service! 💚🍋‍🟩

Bronx-Cali Zoo

Google
First time trying Cait's Key Lime Pie that was given to me by a close friend. I couldn't believe how delicious this pie tastes! It really hit the spot! It's lemony sweet, mouthwatering, addictive and packs a punch that's full of flavors too!! I actually saved the lid, this way I can order some in the near future especially during the upcoming holidays. 😁🤦‍♂️💚