Cait's Key Lime

Bakery · Downtown Brooklyn

1

@infatuation

"The next time you find yourself at a rooftop barbecue or a park hang, bring a key lime pie. When everyone else unveils their store-bought guac and chips or six-pack of canned wine, you’ll be the hero, especially if the pie is from Cait’s Key Lime. These pies are made to order and come in three sizes, Goldilocks-style. The filling is smooth and pudding-like, with an ideal combination of tartness and sweetness, and each pie is topped with a generous layer of whipped cream and zest. There’s no physical storefront, but you can order the larger sizes online for pickup or delivery, or find mini pies at Sweet Chick locations around town. photo credit: Britt Lam" - Britt Lam

Cait’s Key Lime - Review - Brooklyn - New York - The Infatuation
Britt Lam

Willoughby Street & Jay Street, Brooklyn, NY 11201 Get directions

caitskeylime.com
@caitskeylime

1 Postcard

See full details

More Places For You

Casa Dani

Spanish restaurant · Chelsea

Tucked in the bustling Citizens NY, Casa Dani offers an airy, stylish backdrop for elevated Spanish and Mediterranean bites from renowned chef Dani García.

9 Postcards

7th Street Burger Times Square

Hamburger restaurant · Midtown West

Nestled in the heart of Times Square, 7th Street Burger serves up juicy smashburgers and crispy fries in a chill spot that oozes casual vibes.

2 Postcards

Felix Roasting Co.

Coffee shop · Midtown East

Step into Felix Roasting Co. for a luxurious coffee experience in a chic, artfully designed space, where every sip of espresso drinks and pastries feels like a small indulgence.

1 Postcard

Oxomoco

Mexican restaurant · Greenpoint

This airy Mexican spot boasts a cozy vibe, stellar wood-fired dishes, and a lively patio perfect for sipping on killer cocktails like the guava margarita.

52 Postcards

Glady's

Caribbean restaurant · Crown Heights

Experience vibrant island vibes at Glady's, a lively Caribbean eatery serving up flavorful jerk dishes and knockout cocktails in Brooklyn.

9 Postcards

odo

Authentic Japanese restaurant · Flatiron District

Tucked away, this acclaimed Japanese spot offers inventive tasting menus and a cozy outdoor vibe—perfect for an elevated, intimate dining experience.

20 Postcards

Adda Indian Canteen

Indian restaurant · Long Island City

Nestled in a quirky space adorned with newspapers, Adda Indian Canteen offers an elevated twist on traditional Indian dishes, all served with a side of warm hospitality.

64 Postcards

Veselka Williamsburg

Ukrainian restaurant · Williamsburg

Veselka has made its way to Williamsburg, bringing iconic Ukrainian comfort food and cozy diner vibes, all without the lines of the East Village.

8 Postcards

Footprints Cafe

Jamaican restaurant · Coney Island

Footprints Café is a Caribbean culinary escape in Coney Island, serving vibrant jerk chicken, flavorful Rasta Pasta, and lively music, perfect for a fun night out.

4 Postcards

Carmenta’s

Italian restaurant · Bushwick

Carmenta’s in Bushwick is your go-to for hearty Italian-American sandwiches and house-made pasta, all delivered with a side of casual charm.

11 Postcards