Dan P.
Yelp
Ever since this spot opened up, I've been hearing stories about a) how amazing it is, and b) how expensive it is. Now, I'm not one to talk (though I do) about how expensive things are - let's face it, dining at Casa SaltShaker isn't cheap by BA standards. Then again, for us$80, or roughly 1600 pesos, we offer up a five course menu that includes a small cocktail, five glasses of wine, mineral water, and coffee, and, of course, the whole social aspect of the communal table. So if Casa Cavia is coming in at similar prices for their meals, who I am to kick? They may not have the whole social aspect, but damn that's a pretty garden centered dining room. It's a stunning setting to dine in - or, in this case, to brunch in, one Sunday while I was out and about.
Now, at brunch, if you want to do the whole thing, it's a four course meal that starts with a bread/cereal course, then a choice of salad or sandwich, then a main course, and then dessert. It runs 1200 pesos and includes mineral water and coffee (although that goes up if you opt for the steak main course, 1 of only 3 options, at which point you pay 1550 pesos). Now, that's $60, which is pricey, but not really outrageous for a top quality brunch. I also realized that after just getting back from vacation in Lima, I wasn't really kicking about those prices on meals, and several of them were in the same range. However, it also sounded like a lot of food. I decided to go a la carte and order a salad and sandwich from the second course options. It's worth noting that if you order a la carte, you could do the four-course brunch from as inexpensively as 1100 pesos, actually saving 100 over the fixed price, with the cheapest option in each round, on up to 1810 if you go the most expensive in each. Unlike many brunches at higher end places, it doesn't include any alcohol. And, interestingly, despite my sitting literally right in front of the bar, I was never offered a drink, in fact, I was never given either the cocktail or wine menu - I even at one point asked about them, as every other table seemed to have them, to which the response was, "yes, we have them" - but they weren't brought to me. I mean, I could have demanded a drink, and a good Bloody Mary at brunch is a favorite, if they have them, and I could have asked a second time about the menus, but I was fine without.
"Roasted eggplant, caramelized tomato, and cottage cheese" was my pick of the three salads. And, it wasn't bad - several long halves of Japanese eggplant cooked down to a texture just verging on being chewy, but managing to stay just on the soft side, and, actual curds of housemade cottage cheese, something we don't get down here. A few too many olives for my tastes, but overall, really good. But is it an $18 dollar salad, i.e., 360 pesos? On to the sandwich, our raison d'etre for this post, and the "roasted lamb, roasted peppers, and criollo sauce" sandwich. We're talking ethereal lamb here. So tender you could eat it with a spoon. And beautifully spiced. And fantastic bread. And these amazing borderline crunch baked potatoes. It certainly blows away the lamb sandwich that was my favorite for eating, though not for paying for, one at Café des Artes at the MALBA museum, which ran the equivalent of $23. This is a mere 440 pesos, or a shade under $22, six years of inflation later. Add in a coffee (isn't that purty?) and a bottle of water, and what would have been impeccable service had it not been for the cocktail/wine menu thing, and did I mention that gorgeous garden setting in which to relax and enjoy? Brunch came in at 980 pesos for all that, plus tip, so we're looking at about $54. Less than some places you could have brunch here, more than many others. And you know what? Worth it. Every peso. Just not something I'm going to do on a regular basis. But dinner for a special occasion is definitely in the offing somewhere down the road.