Sara R.
Yelp
I recently visited Casita, the fine dining Mexican spot on Ventura Blvd in Sherman Oaks, to celebrate a friend's birthday, and it was overall a fantastic experience.
First, parking is either via valet or metered street parking, which is convenient enough. We kicked things off at the bar for happy hour, and let me just say--the happy hour menu is amazing. Danny "with a Y," the bartender, was a total standout. He was attentive, friendly, and really made the experience enjoyable. I ordered the spicy passion fruit margarita, and it was incredibly delicious. It could've used a bit more sweetness and less lime, but that's just personal preference.
We enjoyed some light bites at the bar--calamari, yellowtail crudo, shrimp ceviche, and chips. Everything was excellent, though I felt the yellowtail crudo was a bit overpowered by the toppings and other flavors. The calamari and ceviche, on the other hand, were spot on.
For dinner, we had a reservation and were seated in a cozy round booth, which was perfect for our group. It made for a comfortable, intimate setting to enjoy our meal together. We ordered a variety of tacos, the little gems salad, and oysters. The tacos were flavorful, and the salad was light and fresh, but let's talk about those oysters--the tiniest oysters I've ever seen. I'm not exaggerating. The shells were smaller than a silver dollar, and we could barely see the actual oysters because they were smothered in chopped onions and sauce. It was definitely a strange experience, but Alex, the manager, was incredibly apologetic and tried to make it right.
Our server, Eli, was amazing--super attentive and really made sure we had a great time. Despite the oyster situation, we loved our food and the overall vibe at Casita. I would definitely return for another celebration or a casual night out.
Highly recommend it for anyone looking for a fun and upscale Mexican dining experience!