Corner Slice

This is a great neighborhood spot. The pizza is fresh even by the slice. It stays fairly busy to where fresh pizza continues to sling out of the oven. The crust is crispy, light and airy, sauce has good flavor, and high quality ingredients are used. I had the Margherita, pepperoni, white, and upside down slices. That is also the order of what I like from best to least. On a 10 point scale in the same order I give 8.3, 8.2, 7.9, 7.7 on a one bite scale.

Absolutely love their square pizzas! The crust is thick but still incredibly crispy and airy. We tried the buffalo chicken, pepperoni, and two vodka slices. One slice was a bit over-toasted during reheating, but overall, the pizza was crunchy and delicious. Definitely looking forward to coming back!!

My husband and I are frequent fliers of this spot. If they had a punch card we would have filled it up a few times over by now. They really do have me questioning my NY roots that scream the best pizza is in NY… because now it is in Maplewood NJ. Please never leave this spot because we love you and your pizza so much!

I have been going to Corner Slice since they were open in Manhattan and was thrilled they opened in Maplewood. Their pizza is delicious. The crust is light and crispy. The pizza itself (all varieties tried so far such as the upside down and the cheese and margherita). Looking forward to trying their garlic knots, babka muffins and more fun specials!

Their pizza is sorcery, they love their community, they’re constantly trying to improve (somehow?) and experiment with new and exciting side items (let’s make a “garlic not” the size of a bowling ball please) … and most importantly, they are immediately beloved in a thriving part of Maplewood that only becomes more and more exciting by the day. But, again, the pizza - unique and from the brains of mad scientists - five stars isn’t enough, this place is the best.

I live 40 mins away. I wanted to try the special pie at the time, asparagus and chive. Fantastic flavor. I’ve made the trip two more times for the pork roll Hawaiian, the cheeseburger slice and the garlic not. Hawaiian wasn’t my favorite but still good. Cheeseburger was great. And the knot/not is a fun take on a classic. The when they have the sheet cake, gotta get it. As for the regular rotation of slices. All have very good. The Garbage slice is my favorite. I’d to the 40 min drive just for that. The specials and the collaborations they do with other restaurants keep me curious. The food is high quality and the crust is just really fcking good. And if you’re into punk rock, the bathroom is badass. Parking can be a pain at times tho but don’t let that stop you.

Great pizza! We ordered the garbage pie and it did not disappoint. They have specials when you walk in…2 cheese slices and a drink and also 2 any kind of slices and a drink. Can order whole pies on their ordering service. I recommend grabbing a pie and heading to Pallet Brewing (5 minute walk).

I went to the grand opening, a homecoming for chef and pizzaiolo Mike Bergemann, who relocated his acclaimed NYC slice shop to his native New Jersey. The space exudes nostalgic charm, featuring neon signage and red-and-black tile floors, creating a warm, retro ambiance. Corner Slice specializes exclusively in square pies, offering a unique "New York Square Pie" that bridges the gap between Sicilian and Grandma styles. The dough undergoes a meticulous three-day fermentation process, resulting in a crust that's light, airy, and crisp, with a distinctive crackly bottom from baking in olive oil-coated pans. I sampled the Upside Down, Vodka, and Pepperoni slices. The Upside Down featured mozzarella beneath a layer of vibrant tomato sauce, delivering a bright and nostalgic flavor. The Vodka slice offered a creamy, slightly spicy sauce complemented by thin shavings of mozzarella. The Pepperoni slice was topped with crispy, cupped pepperoni, adding a satistying savory note. While the craftsmanship and quality of ingredients are evident, personal taste preferences vary. For those who appreciate innovative takes on classic square slices, Corner Slice presents a compelling option in the New Jersey pizza landscape.

Not knowing they were open - we wandered by to see that they were ready and had pizza's ready We tried a couple of slices - wow! Square pizzas where the base was so light and airy and the toppings were so fresh and flavorful Must try! Well worth it

4.25 but Yelp, so rounding down. Really good pizza! Crispy yet light and airy at the same time. Not overcooked or burned. If you want a thick piece of pie with the right amount of chew and crisp, this is the spot. We got pepperoni, Margherita, and cheese. All were delicious. Only negative was the seats and table were dirty and we had to wipe them down ourselves. Only two other tables had occupants when we showed up around 1.45pm on a Sunday

Amazing square pizza. I highly recommend going here if you enjoy super crunchy flavorful square slice pizza. The menu is pretty simple as is the seating at corner slice. Of the slices I tried my top choice would def be their garbage pie which has red onion sausage jalapeño. This is just so flavorful. Can't wait to go back

They do what they do really well. Their slices remind me of Pizza Hut pan pie back in the 70s/80s if you're old enough to remember that. Crispy, light, airy, and the bottom of the crust is slightly oily, in a good way, as in not dry. I'm not usually a crust eater but I actually ate a fair bit of my crust. Service is good and they bring it to your table if they're not busy. The vibe is classic corner pizza joint with some funky touches like the old sign from their former city spot. Make sure to check out all the cool stickers in the bathroom!

This place is sure innovative! Owners experimenting in the back room with flavor combos...some perhaps not exactly what you would expect or want (hamburger slice, Pizza Hut style slice) but all ingredients are fresh. Pepperoni was the favorite though the white slice could have used a bit more flavor. Outside seating under the mural has Portland vibes and a nice addition to the neighborhood for sure!

What a special treat of a (mostly) take-out pizza place nestled in a neighborhood off the beaten path! The square pizza "by-the-slice" has such a hearty yet light crust that holds up to the delicious sauce, cheese, and toppings. You order your slice(s) to be warmed up for you (awesome meal deals for sure) and try to grab one of the few seats. I love the cherry pepper bomb that makes any slice spicy, but the garbage pizza is one of the best slices for sure. There is a slice for just about everyone, from the regular plain and pepperoni to the vodka or upside down. What a fun place to add to your pizza rotation if you like to shake it up now and again!

First time and will definitely not be your last! Delicious pizza and great flavor variety. Full pies and slices available with quick and efficient service. Eat in at a clean and "pizza parlor" ambiance.

Excellent pizza! I would call it Detroit style but I'm no expert. Crispy crust that reminded me of Pizza Hut, if Pizza Hut were really high quality. Great fresh ingredients. Check this place out!

Meh. I really wanted to love this place. But I was underwhelmed. It's expensive, tastes just ok. Slim pickings. Tried a few slices too. It's a nice addition to the neighborhood, but I won't be driving out of my way to go there.

Adorable new locale for pizza in Maplewood NJ. Loved the vibe but the pizza isn't for me. The sauce was too much tomatoes and might have caused a bad reflux attack. It tasted great but the tummy wasn't happy.

Good, crispy crust. Could use more in toppings & sauce-wise, but still good. Glad I tried it. Best wishes!

Was a former regular at their NYC location and now happy to see it open near by. Stopped by the soft opening over the weekend and tried each of the white, Margherita, upside down and plain cheese, The pizza is so light and delicious and service was fast! Can't wait to come back once they have a larger menu for a sandwich and other treats. Another great option on that block!

Nice building, clean restaurant. I wish they had tap water available. Also, the price are pretty high for the size of the slice that you receive. The slices do taste good, they are just so oily and greasy. My fingers were dripping in oil after eating the pepperoni slice. The service was also quite slow, and the employee putting pizza in the oven to heat the slices only put in three to four slices at a given time. I don't blame her, though because it didn't appear she had a big enough counter to box up slices anyways. Overall, tasty but probably increases your risk of cardiovascular diseases.

Slices are great (recommend the margarita), and for this day and age, priced reasonably. Light and crunchy. Great flavor. If you know NJ pizza, you'll agree that there isn't a better square slice for miles. Let's support this new pizza joint!

Corner Slice serves square slices with a nice airy crust that is still crispy somehow. The ingredients and sauce are all high quality and very tasty. Eventually, they will offer whole pies and possibly some additional menu items. This is a very good place. It is easy to see why they got so much publicity in NYC.

Good crust. Friendly staff. Ok location. Nice selection of pizzas. My grandson loved it

So I don't leave many reviews unless something really gets to me that I think is important for the owner or the public to know. I was there this past Sunday (2/16/25) just before 2p and ordered many slices for my family. We ate them there. They were good. My husband really liked the crust. Fine. But I'm not going back. Why? (1) Woman behind the counter saw that we were ordering a lot of slices (9/qty) and never pointed out the special which would have saved us money. (2) The woman behind the cash register, when asked if there was tap water and cups, pointed over my shoulder said, "Cups are there" with a tone which conveyed "leave me alone." She did not say, "I'm sorry, we don't offer tap water. We have bottled beverages you can buy." (3) That same employee behind the register was hating her job while dealing with the public--she was unfriendly, un-kind, un-helpful. So If I want attitude, I'll ask my teenage sons a question, but when I'm spending $60+ for counter pizza, you have got to be kidding me that I'm going to deal with attitude. And there was a tip jar! Omg make me lol. Owner: You need to "spy" on your staff by sending your friends in in your place to find out which of your employees really wants her job and who doesn't. Good luck. Not going back.

Had the most delicious pizza today at Corner Slice!! We tasted the plain, garbage and buffalo chicken slices. The crust was crunchy, light and delicious, And the toppings were so yummy. I can't wait to go back and try the others!!