Mark W.
Yelp
Fantastic dishes. Oysters were high quality and a good variety when we got the chef's choice. Sea Bass was absolutely delicious with the beurre blanc and mushrooms but the lobster risotto was even better. A fantastic lemon rhubarb something or other for dessert. I think it was a special that night and not on the regular menu. I'd say the service was between adequate and good. Nothing particular to complain about, but nothing over the top either.
Some good and bad when it comes to libations, though. And as you know, if the wine isn't at least 50% of your dining experience, you're doing it wrong. Don't argue with me, you're just wrong. On a positive note, the $15 corkage fee is extremely reasonable. Our server also brought the correct glasses, including volunteering an ice bucket, as was appropriate for the particular wine, without having to even ask. She was also competent in opening and properly serving our wine. That feels like such a low bar for expectations, but it's shocking how rare that is in Utah.
On the down side, we didn't want to drink our Batard Montrachet with the oysters, because, well, that would be insane (it went gloriously with the entrees, however), so we ordered a couple glasses of sparkling off the menu for our starter. The choices were quite limited in that department. After automatically dismissing two of the offerings as non-starters, we were left with only a Cremant de Bourgogne, which was serviceable, but not quite the right pairing. Our server also didn't seem to have much of a background in wines, and got the sense if we hadn't brought our own and needed recommendations, she would have just spit out the generic lines her boss told her to push for the week. So for me, I'm used to bringing my own or capable of navigating a wine menu like Ferdinand Fucking Magellan, but a hint of advice for our server; you're doing a pretty good job, but brush up on your wine knowledge and do some regular tastings to beef up your background when someone who isn't me comes in. I'll end on a positive note, though, as I still gave them 5 stars... again, the lobster risotto was absolutely fantastic!