Jonghan L.
Yelp
Get ready for some elevated, bougie hot pot experience! Came here on a Thursday night at 7pm with a party of 3. Crowd was starting to form, and the restaurant was about ~70% capacity. We had a reservation down so we were immediately seated by Rolanny, who took care of our reservation. We ordered a whole lot of food (see bill/check photo), including but not limited too: wagyu beef cubes ($35), house special beef platter ($35), kurobata pork, kung fu tripe, fish tofu, spicy beef, filet of fish (sole), cuttlefish paste, wood ear mushroom, enoki mushroom, A/taiwanese lettuce and the sauce and broths. Total bill came out to $210 for three people and we were royally stuffed.
AMBIANCE:
Decor here is fancy! Decor is gorgeous, with modernist twist on Chinese aesthetics. Restaurant has a beautiful backdrop, and has two floors with meandering pathways to different tables and private rooms. This restaurant definitely knocks it out of the park in comparison to Tang Hotpot or DaLongYi, their closest competitors at the similar price point and experience.
PROS:
The quality of ingredients is on point! Lets first talk about the concept of the restaurant and how it is different compared to other bougie hot pot spots. At Da Yu, each person orders their individual broth (which costs $5-15 depending on your broth and if you order the two/three broth per pot option), and you have about ~8 choices of broth to choose from. Love this idea as it probably is more sanitary to have your own individual pot and better control what goes inside your own soup. I opted for the tomato and oxtail soup broth, which was incredibly flavorful, packs a lot of umami flavors from the tomato, and there was even a giant piece of slow cooked oxtail with meat inside! My friends opted for the Da Yu hot pot and the pork pelly with tripe soup, and they really enjoyed it as well. Da Yu pot looked delicious as it had a plethora of vegetables and mushrooms in it.
The menu is quite expansive with a wide selection of meats, seafood, vegetables, and drinks (and also sashimi? lol) to choose from. Menu is predominantly in Chinese with small English subtitles, so non-Chinese speaking folks be aware of that.
Presentation and quality of the food was ridiculous (not sure if the added aesthetic adds much to the flavor, but it does make it look pretty). Like for instance our wagyu beef cubes came covered with the glass domes used for smoke machines, and the cuttlefish paste was served in a chandelier/lamp plate apparatus. Each cut of meat was also served elegantly, especially the house special beef platter, which included wagyu cubes, sliced wagyu, ox tongue etc.
Favorite menu items were honestly the wagyu cubes and the house meat platter. Meat was so juicy and tender, literally melts in your mouth! Other highlights include the cuttlefish paste, the tofu bean curd (never had tofu that good in any other restaurant before), and the kurobota pork belly was so delicious and juicy. The marbling and quality on some of these meats is a little crazy, and the plating style really does elevate the quality of the meat and the experience. Vegetables were really fresh, and portion sizes were decent for the price that you get. Sole filet was very fresh too and that really works well with the tomato soup broth, and the kung fu tripe as the waiters put it were really incredible. Highly recommend those aforementioned items in your next visit!
For drinks, we orderd the wangzai milk, jia duo bao (herbal team) and a pitcher of their lemon kumquat juice. The kumquat juice was the highlight as it was housemade, and the acidity and sweetness of the juice really helps cut down the beefiness of the meal that you're going to get!
Sauce bar was pretty expansive and had a wide variety of options to choose from. Not sure if this was on purpose, but we weren't able to find the soy sauce there (should be a standard item). But notwithstanding, their house made Xo seafood oyster sauce was incredible! Pungent, tangy, smokey, and sweet. I also love the fact that on top of the sauce bar you can have unlimited refills on their spicy tripe and kim chi as a cold appetizer - those were great too!
Finally, staff was incredible. Rolanny did a great job explaining to us about the concept of the restaurant and soliciting feedback for them to improve. Our servers were attentive and constantly helped us add/refill water, and our food came out at a rapid pace. Our servers even recommended us cooking times for certain items, and one even helped portioned the cuttle fish paste so the three of us get equal amounts in our broth. Thank you Da Yu staff for such a wonderful service that night! Be prepared though, the staff is definitely more comfortable speaking in mandarin, so it might be difficult to communicate in english if there isn't a mandarin speaker in your party.
OVERALL:
Best high end hot-pot experience I've had in NYC! This knocks it out of the park for me, and I will come back hungry for more!