Brooke C.
Yelp
Wow, this was a BAD dinner experience, which I'm pained to say since Edwin's-Edwin's is my favorite restaurant in town and I love the mission of the organization.
We came here for my birthday before going to the orchestra. I had waited too long to make a reservation at Edwin's, but was thrilled to see an opening at 6 at Edwin's Too. So the first part of our bad experience is partly my fault: we'd never been, the website is hard to navigate and provides almost no info, so when I finally found a menu it was (spoiler alert) not actually for Edwin's Too, but for Edwin's. So we booked unaware that there was a set menu and that for our night it was nothing I would actually want to spend $50 on.
So that part is my bad, though honestly, the website should clearly state what the nature of the dinner experience is. What's inexcusable is the glacially slow service. Bear in mind that when we arrived at 6, there was one other party. I asked for a minute to consider my drink order . . . and no one came back for 15-20. Our first course arrived at about 6.45 (Cobb salad should not take that long when it's literally the only first course and we're one of two parties) and our steaks after 7. At this point we were getting worried. We informed our server that we had to leave by 7.30, so we'd take the check now and take our dessert to go. She was prompt with the check, but told us the dessert wasn't ready yet. That was fine . . . until it was 7.35 and we had to book it out of there without ever getting our dessert. No one seemed to notice or care that we were leaving without one of the courses we had paid for--I had wanted to have a quiet word with the hostess, but she wasn't at her station.
In sum: in 90 minutes, the house could barely get us our two simple courses (salad and steak) and never got us our dessert. The food was well-prepared, but not worth $50 a person and I feel misled about the nature of the dining experience. We have a toddler and rarely get out, so I'm crushed to have wasted a nice meal out on food I would never have ordered--and not even to have gotten all that we paid for. I'll never return to Edwin's Too and right now feel pretty sour on Edwin's as well.
Dining experience = 2 stars. 3 stars only because I feel partly responsible for my bad night out.