LT Burger Sag Harbor

LT Burger in Sag Harbor is a fantastic spot for a casual yet delicious lunch. The atmosphere is lively and inviting, with a cool, retro-inspired diner vibe that makes you feel right at home. They offer a great selection of burgers, from classic beef to turkey, veggie and even a Montauk tuna burger. The smash burger style ensures a juicy patty with a perfect sear. Don't skip the sides – the curly fries are perfectly crispy. And if you're feeling indulgent, their milkshakes are legendary, with creative flavors like S'mores and Death by Oreo. I also really enjoyed the kiwi ginger juice. The service is friendly and efficient, adding to the overall positive experience. It's the kind of place that's perfect for a family meal or a relaxed bite with friends while exploring the charming village of Sag Harbor.

Had a great milkshake - 'Gone Bananas (banana 🍌 dulce de leche) & 'LT backyard' burger 🍔 that was really tasty and on point , not huge in size but hits the spot. Really friendly, helpful, and courteous staff. I highly recommend LT burger

Food was good but had a few problems with the menu. It was advertised as items came with cheese and then was charged 3$ for cheese on a burger. It also said it was 2$ for bacon and was also charged 3$ for it. Also there were no free refills on a fountain soda, makes no sense. None of this was a big deal it should just be mentioned before we order or mentioned on the menu! I recommend the bleu cheese burger and the gouda fries as well!

Delivered burnt food (chicken wings) and did not label group order placed on Ubereat which made it very difficult to know which burger was whose. The whole thing was a big mess and a frustrating experience.

manager was very rude and the service staff was inexperienced. 3 twenty-year-olds went in and ordered chicken tenders however they treat us like children. The 80-year-old couple next to us, got a larger drink order than us, despite ordering the same thing. we received more toys than food in our kitty to go box placed on a plate. and more oranges than fries. do not order from here and do not talk to the manager. it was not made clear that we were being served as children beforehand despite paying $75 for three chicken, tender boxes of toys. overpriced, rude, and areogant. when we questions the manager about this, since there was no warning that we were being served as children he said “but there are toys so enjoy” no apologizing or making his customer feel welcomed! The waiter also was watching us tip him to pressure more for him. they should have put a better first experience for all their customers since they are new and I will not be going back

It was a wonderful place to dine. The menu is delightful ( little small ) but offers a variety of options. The smash burgers were particularly enjoyable! This charming spot is a great find. It is also more budget-friendly compared to some of the other establishments in the area, as it has a more relaxed dress code. The atmosphere is casual and has a very cool vibe. You can also sit outside and dine right on main street.

Absolutely love this place! You do have to know what you’re getting as far as noise because it’s very family, friendly, but as long as you set your expectations, all is good in the world! The food is incredible, some of the best burgers, especially the crispy chicken try that for sure. Service is good, the wine list is surprisingly good! The beers are fantastic, and the cocktails are as good as you might imagine. Go here now!

I used to go to this place a few years ago and it was my favorite, but since they reopened it feels like a completely new place trying to capitalize on a popular old name. The apps were good, but the thing that used to be amazing (the burgers) are all just okay now. I was super excited to see one of my favorite places come back, but unfortunately the burgers are pretty boring. (Not every burger needs to be smashed). Staff were nice, and responsive but this new version of LT burger is not something I would recommend. Especially for the price.

Z‍ The service was amazing, they helped me choose the LT backyard burger which I think is a very solid burger. there's nothing absolutely but I enjoyed every bite. Didn't try their fries but they look good. I could see 'em at a couple of tables, taking a peek, peeping like a Tom, and they look good. I want to come back and try all their burgers though. I'm so happy they're back. I never even once understood why they changed it to a taco joint when K Pasa is right down the street. And they own K Pasa. Truly bizarre. Did they think the tequila demand was that high? Anyhoops, I recommend this place and it's solid as a rock. A burger rock. Since my, T.J. Miller - the original yelp gangster

'LT backyard' burger that was really tasty and on point , not huge in size but hits the spot. Really friendly, helpful, and courteous staff. I highly recommend LT burger

So this place was a staple in Sag Harbor. But unfortunately, it closed down for two summers to become a mid Mexican place, but now it's open back up very disappointed to say it's not as good as it used to be. They fell to the trend of Smashburgers

Dude, I'm not gonna lie this Berger place you should be so good a few years ago but now it's ass. My other review was just because I rated it before I actually even went there so I actually didn't even know what I was talking about. The burgers were like ugly asf and I'm for real. Like deaduzz. In the plate were all cheap everything which is cheapest.

Underwhelming. Last year they had a Mexican concept that was wonderful- really flavorful food and fun menu. This year it's back to burgers, and the restaurant leaves much to be desired. Feels like there's no management and it's sort of a free for all. The food is just "ok". Salads are TINY. Seared tuna has a strange tasting rub on it (good quality tuna should have nothing on it) and the kids meals come with a bunch of candy that no one wants their kids to consume. I've been here 3x this summer solely because it's easy to get into. I likely won't be back again.

They're back but TBD if better. Very glad LT is back as it was very disappointing when they closed the original to open a taco restaurant. That said, my first experience since they reopened was definitely lacking. All I could remember was the delicious tuna burger that I last had in 2022. I tried it last week and was very underwhelmed by the tiny pieces of tuna that I ordered medium but there's no way it could be anything less than well done because the pieces are thin and tiny. That was a disappointment. My cousin who's pescaterian is visiting in a few weeks. I literally had been talking up this tuna burger for three years, but I'm not sure I'll be able to convince her that this is the burger I pined over for years. The sauce on the bun is delicious, however. Hopefully the size of the regular burgers are normal and they will improve the tuna burger over time. I will try again.

They're back! We were Very excited to go. Started off with the fried pickles, Of Course. Everyone's jaw hit the table when he brought them out. There. Were. 7 pickles. DELICIOUS! But 7. What happened to the basket?!! So disappointed All smash burgers. They were good. Gouda fries. DELICIOUS still. My daughter had the rated R shake. DELICIOUS. I had the S'mores. It was okay. Friends had the banana. They loved. The place got a nice redo! Service was great.

this used to be one of our favorite casual restaurants. they reopened and the food is just ... not good at all. Did they sell to a PE firm who bought the name and ruined the experience for all of us?? bummer.

We purchased a Smashburger, which was equivalent in size and taste to a hamburger on the dollar menu at McDonald's and we were sadly disappointed!! The service was decent but we were there for the burger!!!

My burger was raw, my second burger was someone else'd and kits screaming non stop. Forgot about my order, my third since 2 before were incorrect. Where is the manager?

The staff at the front counter are the most entitled group of young women I have ever come across at a restaurant in my life and I've seen some real doozies. You have to try to be this miserable, they really seemed to go out of their way to express their crap demeanor. I write this because after the first interaction I decided to ask some simple questions of two other staffers. Same weird attitude. Working here must be hell to inspire this kind of misery. My condolences. Parents, if your children work here it's not too late to set them on the right path.

The burger was on point, but the service was lacking... quite literally. The FOH was understaffed for it being peak busy season and, even with a half empty restaurant, the service was less than what I would consider the bare minimum, having worked in the restaurant industry for 15 years out here. Kudos to the chef and cooks for a delicious meal, but management and upper management needs to step up their game and hire more staff.

Like every other place out here... This place gets slammed during service. We were there as a group of 8... lucky enough to find a seat. LT earns a higher rating than what yelp is telling you. The beer was cold, the service was attentive and prompt, and the food was good. I'm definitely inclined to go back.

After visiting vineyards with friends we needed some serious food. We decided on LT Burger mainly because it was convenient. There were a good amount of parking spots in the area so you don't have to walk too far. I ordered the LT backyard with a side of sweet potato fries. They also have a lot of combo options where you can add a milkshake with fries or beer etc. where you'd save some money. I really enjoyed my burger and the size was perfect. The sweet potato fries were also great and really crispy. I wish they had different sizes for the fries because there weren't a lot to share with my group of friends. The only thing that was off putting was the service. It seemed like everyone who worked there hated their job. They literally dropped the food and drinks off at our table. None of the staff went over anything and they only came to the table when there was something needed. We took so much time trying to flag someone. There were workers just hanging out there and I wasn't sure if they were on break or just bored. When we asked for our check they had an issues separating our checks which I understand but we didn't order that much and our group wasn't big.

Stopped here after a carnival in town. The place was crowded, as expected, and when told the waitress how many were in our party she just stared at us. When asked if there was a wait, she said I don't know. Clearly if there are no tables there is a wait and we just received a blank stare. We told her to take our number to let us know when a table is open. Table opened up (our party had 2 adults, 4 kids under 7 and one infant). We requested a highchair 3 times before one was brought over. The service was slow. The food was good, however. The kids all loved their boxes with their "surprises" inside. And it was the right amount of food in each. I had the veggie burger and it was huge. Whole it was good, it fell apart and didn't seem like it was cooked or had seared edges. We ordered milkshakes to go while we were still eating and it took almost 20 minutes. To get 4 kids milkshakes. Then the straws were cut too short and the kids couldn't even use the straws to drink due to them falling into the cup. Overall, it's worth another try as it's one of the only kid friendly places in town but not my first option.

Ok. I don't like Sag Harbor. It's pretentious and full of inconvenient stores with obscene prices. I mean really, is a Starbucks that bad? Anyhow, I gave in and tried one more time with LT Burger. Bay Burger made my wife sick and we love burgers. All the Sag Harborites praise this, and actually anything in Sag Harbor, as the most divine experience ever. You actually can't criticize anything about Sag Harbor to anyone here. There is no other solution. They need a solution other than LT burger. Service sucks, bartender ignored my wife for 30 minutes. They couldn't grasp we were a party of five and kept taking us to a table for four. They eventually took the order then the waitress disappeared. Finally - the food arrived. Not bad and not great. Soggy bacon and bland beef. Cheese has no flavor. I guess they don't use salt here? Just plain. My daughter ordered a burger well done, which was not even close. Another disappointment from Sag Harbor. I'm done.

a very social and cute place. Takeout gets a little soggy but eating there is just fine.

I've been to Sag Harbor a few times and walked by LT Burger looking in thinking "this looks like a cool place." It's got this neon hamburger sign on the inside that just catches the eye. I had the standard burger with cheese and fries on the side. From a flavour profile standpoint, it's okay. It's not spectacular but the burger is cooked to your preference and they nailed my request for medium. My issue is the size of burger. It's this massive 8oz thing which looks like a hockey puck in a bun. Awkward to eat due to its size unless you have a mouth the size of Trump- yet his small hands wouldn't be able to hold this thing so moot point.

Why on earth does this place have 3 starts out of 5? a little bit pricey but finally a vegetarian burger spot that has TWO options - the impossible burger or the standard beet/black bean/rice burger. the outdoor seating is perfectly fine with covid and they allow you to be seated with your dog. we came here summer 2019 + will be back over and over again... a must for sag harbor. ~T

Death by Oreo milkshake is great, but extremely overpriced. I've been coming to LT burger for years and have gotten the death by Oreo shake when they originally created it with coffee ice cream instead of chocolate. I ordered one last night after dinner across the street and was shocked at the increased price. It went from $7 to $18 ($20 with tax). This increased payment is fine but the cashier deceptively didn't say anything about price until the very end and the price was removed from the upper-chalkboard menu. Further, the milkshake decreased in size but they served it with an ice cream sandwich to justify the increased compensation. The ice cream sandwich was one of the worst I've had.

For a cheap burger place, this restaurant is solid. I know it's not cheap cheap, but it's for sure Hamptons cheap. When I called around 6pm, they said a to go order would take 15-20 mins to prepare, but by 6:45pm when I actually called to place my order, I was quoted 25-30 mins which is still relatively quick. Just be prepared to call several times before you get through to them to place a pick up order, they do not have call waiting. I was ordering for 3 people and they got all of our orders correct. Their online menu is outdated and they no longer serve the Beyond burger, so I got an Impossible burger on their multigrain bun. The flavors were really good, but there was too much bread compared to the size of the burger (which was a large burger). I ended up eating it on only 1 half of the bun and it was a much better taste ratio. All in all this is a good choice for a quick and cheap meal in the area.

Not worth a visit. Very mediocre overpriced burgers. Overcooked no matter how you order them. Bad service - you'll never get a refill on your drink. No one checks in on you. Have to beg for the menu, order be taken, or to get the bill. Only 2 washrooms. Just go anywhere else!

They had Fox News playing in the television in the dining room. I'm never going back. It also took them 20 minutes to take our order in an empty restaurant. The food was good and the portion was decent, but not worth the prices. Better off going to Fellinghams in Southampton

Just had lunch at LT and it was the worst. Burger was very dry asked for cheese didnt get any told them and they took it back to add cheese now it overcooked and cold . Told the waitress and she said nothing . Will NOT go back there again

Thanks to Joe, who was The Bartender today. So this is a Burger Restaurant that accepts credit cards as payment and shares it's parking lot with neighboring businesses, so parking space may not always be close by. As you enter, you'll notice that there's outdoor dining available and inside has plenty of seating for small to midsize groups of people to attend. The Bar Area is placed in the middle of the room, in a U-Shape and in the opposite side is a cafe. There's about 10 beers on tap, with a fairly large and diverse menu of food to select from that includes a Kid's Menu and various choices in dessert. They offer Arcade Games such as Pac-Man, Candy Machine, Free WiFi, Multiple TV's, and Music. They also provide take out through dial-in or online ordering and delivery service with DoorDash. This place has a cozy and relaxing atmosphere about it and is worth checking out. Thanks to Matt, who was The Bartender today.

No sense in writing a nasty review. Everything that was wrong w/ our to go order you can read in everyone else's reviews. Avoid this place at all costs. Hopefully whoever occupies this space next will do a better job. 1 star for almost trying.

I have been here a couple of times, always in the middle of the day so its pretty quiet. I come here for one thing the impossible burger with vegan cheese, this has become my benchmark to measure all other vegan Burgers by. Its by far one of the best i have had and the reason why i keep coming back. All they need is to add a vegan shake, please.

It kills me to leave a negative review, but this is in the hopes someone does something about the issues plaguing this place, which actually delivers some quality burgers! The burgers are delicious! But the service is horrendous - the servers and bartenders themselves are sweet and polite and wonderful, but the food takes a preposterous amount of time to get out of the kitchen. It should be called LaTe Burger. I believe new management is the reason behind this - this place used to be awesome, the food is still solid, but I'll never set food in here again because a single burger takes an hour and a half...

Everything was fantastic. The bbq nachos, our burgers, and the chocolate milkshakes were delicious! We will definitely be going back.

We came here on a fairly busy fall day, and while the ambiance is nice, it was a mediocre experience at best. Now the food was fine (I had the Impossible burger), the service was sub par to say the least. The waitress seemed to only be handling 3 or 4 tables but we had to ask for everything - water, drinks, etc. Not sure if the WHB location is better but I'm going to try that spot and will report back.

Disappointed I used to Love this place My whole family did We went again as a celebration And boy were we disappointed The burgers were cold and lacked the deliciousness they used to have It seems they have let go of what used to make this place my go to in sag harbor I hope they get their act back tou

We have dined her three times and I can confidently say their food is quality and consistent. The burgers are cooked perfect to order and flavorful. The fried and onions rings are enjoyable and prepared properly. The hospitality does the best to accommodate, although the servers seem to always be in the weeds and it is apparent they are stressed out.

Ordered takeout on a late Sunday afternoon, told to pickup at 3:38, 20 minutes after I ordered (one chicken sandwich and a soda) got to the restaurant and it was literally empty and my food still wasn't ready. Stood around for ten more minutes - so in total waited 30 minutes in an empty restaurant for one sandwich. Also, it was advertised as having hot sauce and sour cream on it- which it didn't, and they added chili to the sandwich which I certainly didn't expect or want? Overall strange and disappointing.

Called in an order at around 7:20. Girl on the phone was friendly and nice, but was clearly inexperienced. Didn't know what type of dressings were offered, which is not a huge deal, but it's the little things that count. I ordered a mixed-green salad with grilled chicken. When I arrived about 20 minutes after I had placed my order, I went up to the counter to pay and I got my order. I had asked the person who took my order (who also happened to be the one who I paid) whether or not the salad had chicken. Rather than checking the salad, she merely looked at the ticket and said "yes, it does." Fast forward to when I walked out of the restaurant and in fact my salad did not have grilled chicken, as I had suspected when she charged me the price of the mixed-green salad without the grilled chicken. I went back and she was taking a phone order, so her colleague, who didn't look much older than 15 years old, helped me. I explained to her my situation and she remedied it quickly. However, when I was explaining my predicament, she showed me the ticket which did not have grilled chicken, which meant that the person who took my order took it incorrectly. I went to eat my food, and the plastic silverware that was packed in there was a spoon and a knife, but no fork. I'm not sure how one would be able to eat a salad with only those utensils. Also, a few ketchup packets were stuffed in the bag, as well as a few in the salad. I've never heard of anybody who puts ketchup on salad. The chicken was lukewarm, and the salad had too many onions, and the lettuce was dry. As someone who often comes to LT Burger, it is a shame that for the prices they charge, the food is only ever "meh." I truly have never had a fantastic meal here, and I fear that tonight was my last at LT Burger. It's certainly a fine place for burgers, but there are better places to go, although they might be a bit further away. Also - train your staff better! I don't fault these kids too much as they were clearly young and inexperienced, so it is on the manager to ensure that they are taking orders properly.

LT Burger is an another example of Sag Harbor, decent food, good service, somewhat overpriced for what you get. Let's dig in. We stopped by for brunch and had a few items: the Shacked Smoke Burger. Smoked Gouda Fries, Chocolate Chip pancakes, with a side of scrambled eggs, and a Gone Bananas milkshake. Quality wise, everything was pretty good. The burger was cooked exactly as I had asked for it, medium rare. The fries were very nice, with the smoked gouda prepared as more of a dip than a melted cheese. The jalapenos and scallions add a nice flavor to it. The scrambled eggs were pretty standard, though I was surprised to see the cheese we asked for melted on top rather than mixed in. The shake was incredible! If you're in the modd for a milkshake, its worth it. The pancakes were good, but the chocolate chips were, flavor-wise, over powering. Service is good, with the staff being friendly and attentive. The style is a cross between a burger place from the 80s and the 50s, clean and neat and fun. It can get rather noisy due to the style of the layout. What we had was good and we were satisfied, but we felt it was rather pricey for that you get. I feel like we could have gotten this meal, plus a round or two of drinks in Brooklyn for a very similar price. Not sure whether or not I can recommended it, maybe if you're in Sag Harbor and really really really need burger...

Always disappoints. I don't understand how a shop that does nothing but hamburgers can make them so dismally. Across the street at Page the burger is bigger, tastier and for the same price comes with fries. Really truly blows my mind that people still eat there. Two small 8oz burgers, one side of fries and two 12 oz milk shakes = $60. Not worth it. Much better options abound all over town.

Always leave full. Small variety of burger choices but all are good. Delicious shakes. Get them without whipped cream so you get a full shake. All burgers are ala carte, but there is a combo. Many fries choices. Very clean. Staff is hit or miss . Dont generally give the impression that they are happy to be there. But thats MY experience . Drove 1.5 hours to go there 3x this year so its good.

Ordered some burgers and looked promising. Fries and onions were very good. Fried pickles were average, BUT the burgers were just a disappointment. Dripping in grease and essentially raw. The veggie burger was inedible, straight to the garbage. Shakes were very unique, good sized and not usual flavors. But the burgers were just beyond s disappointment and at $115 just no where near worth the money.

I love this place ! It's hard to find a decent meal for a decent price around here. LT Burger is a quintessential burger joint , with awesome milkshakes. It's casual, with an old school feel. The burgers are inventive snd the milkshakes are awesome. However, I have an extreme sensitivity to cilantro and cannot eat it or have it anywhere near my food. I ordered the turkey burger, and when I bit into t I was unpleasantly surprised when I got a mouthful of cilantro. It wasn't on the menu!!! That should have been lettuce not cilantro!!! I pretty much gagged and had to pull my entire burger apart. But alas, the burger was flavorful, the onion rings were crisp , and I got an order of fried Oreos to go to handle my sweet tooth later. Love this place and will be back! But next time, no cilantro.

Ordered a burger, takeout, medium. Simple enough. Got home it was somewhere between raw and rare. My dog enjoyed three-quarters of it. Never again!

Really well done the tuna burger flavor ,hit , right temperature , warm bread perfect execution Thanks chef Noe

After several other restaurants failed in this location, LT Burger hit the mark with super cool decor, great burgers, beautiful salads and amazing milk shakes. A-1 for kids too. Everything in this place seems as it should be. Recommend the Mexican burger if you don't mind the extra spice. Service can be slow on a summer Saturday evening but we are not in Manhattan. Sit back and relax.

Ordered a few burgers with Fam. Server started out attentive brought our drinks over took our order and that was the last we saw of her for 40 minutes. She came back and apologized that no one took our order. I explained that she took our order 40 minutes ago and no one has been back for a refill etc. Server claimed the POS system was down and kitchen never received our order and it would be another 20 minutes. We thanked her and left. Won't be back. Lack of management. Staff seemed to be having a good time together

Happened into LT on a day trip to Sag Harbor and wow. Absolutely delicious burger. Some of the reviews complain of a "greasy burger" I attribute those to city people that just come here to complain and never give anything higher than two stars. This is a classic thick and juicy burger. It's a very thick patty with an excellent selection of toppings. Add to that, a nice beer selection, nice people working there, cool decor and fantastic shakes, and I will definitely go back

I. Been going to Lt burger for years my last visit was not good i ordered the heritage turkey burger as I alway do was surprise that they say it comes with onion roll avocado and yogurt mine had no onion roll no avocado and they substituted the yogurt with mayo and the burger was not the original size very disappointed

LT Burger was clearly a popular place. There were several families with kids off for the summer. The place had a cute, fun atmosphere with the menu colorfully written in chalk on the walls. I had the Standard burger with lettuce, tomato, onions, and pickles. It was basically a good burger. What really stood out was the French toast shake with vanilla ice cream, cinnamon, maple syrup, and whipped cream. It was definitely rich and sinful. They offered other creative shake flavors and there was a whole counter devoted to where they made the shakes and sold other sweets/desserts. LT Burger seemed like a perfect laid back and casual place to go after browsing in the cute, charming shops along Main St. in Sag Harbor.

Don't get food for pickup. I ordered for a large group. None of the burgers were labelled, they were mashed together in the bag, and the fries were cold upon pickup. The sweet potato fries were greasy and soggy. The burgers themselves are good, but I'd recommend the standard burger, as none of their specialty burgers are remarkable. The Mexican burger is terrible, with a sprinkling of promised toppings and bland flavor. Their desserts are excellent, however, and their milkshakes are good too.

Very poor service , terrible with no consideration to people , no accommodation! waiting 45 minutes to get served to find out "they lost the order" and can we wait another 30 minutes to be served NO THANK YOU!!! you will not see me again!

I ordered a number 8 (lettuce wrap) with cheese and bacon to go. I was charged 22 dollars (I guess cheese and bacon costs extra. A lot.) and got a burger in a bun with no bacon. Further, it was definitely not angus beef, it tasted synthetic, could have been veggie. Total disappointment. Note to self, double check your order, even when you're late for a bus