M J.
Yelp
THANKSGIVING 2025 -- a generous review.
Yes, this is overdue, as I reminded myself to write a review when I came across our receipt from the event.
When we stay at the central coast in November, this is our "go-to" place. In the past, we tried this once for Thanksgiving, but could not recall if we liked their T-day dinners or not. I had a feeling that their T-day dinners weren't all that memorable, or we would have remembered them, but I doubted myself and so we made reservations.
The memory came flooding back as we worked our way through the turkey dinners. We both found (again) that the stuffing was unpleasantly dry and the gravy was good, but was rather sparse. The potatoes were okay, but could have been much warmer...bordering room temp/coolish in some spots. I asked for a fork when given my slice of cake after dinner. Jordan (okay, but a bit indifferent) our server brought over a fork, but turned her back and walked away before I could finish seeing the fork and call her back. OMG. It was not just a "little dirty", it was CRUSTED with dried food all over it. ("How could this "chunky" looking fork be overlooked??", I thought. It looked like it was pulled from a dirty dish bin). I called the attention of nearby server so I asked for a clean fork and then showed it to her. She said, not surprisingly, "Eww!"
We still gave a 22% tip because we really like Far Western Tavern and have been going there for many years. Thanksgiving?? NOoooo Way.
If it can't be done right, please management, just let the employees stay home on Thanksgiving and enjoy the time with their families.