Ryan K.
Yelp
My wife and I had heard great things about FioRito and were excited to have a night without the kids to try it out. Maybe our mistake was not trying something from their more standard menu, but we tried their 4 course winter menu because we've had similar multi-course meals from Vora and Elderslie a few times in the past and always loved it.
The first course was a cheddar ale soup, and you could tell that the flavors were all there, but it was just about a notch (or two) too salty and the portion was too large for something so rich. It needed something to cut through the richness, or maybe a nice crusty bread to dip with, as it was almost more like a cheese sauce or dip rather than a soup, and thus it was hard to eat such a large portion of it.
Next was a lamb gnocchi ragu and i was the most excited about this one, but holy cow the Ragu was so salty it was inedible. I love salt, and usually eat food that is saltier than what all my friends prefer, but even I could not eat this. It was a shame because the actual lamb gnocci was beautiful. It was delicate and delicious and you could tell it would have been excellent if the Ragu sauce had not been so over salted, and while I tried to eat just the gnocci there was no avoiding the salt bomb in each bite. It almost makes me wonder if both the soup and this Ragu had just been cooking all day and reducing, causing the flavors of both to really become concentrated and salty.
The third course was an aged strip loin with potato galette fries and this one hit it out of the park! It was excellent. The seasoning was finally on point, the beef demi glaze was a perfect pairing, and the potato galette was like a potato version of a layered pastry... it was wonderful! This was more in line with what we were expecting.
The final course was a Mexican chocolate and spiced orange chantilly mouse. In a somewhat funny, or maybe ironic twist, the orange chantilly was sprinkled with a layer of tajin and orange zest, which meant even the dessert was salty, BUT it actually paired nicely with the richness of the mouse and it wasn't overly salted so it was a nice balance. The flavors were nice, but the whole desert was just mouse with no other texture, so it really felt lacking in complexity as it was just one note and texture, and again the portion was too large if there weren't going to be other textures to break up the monotony.
Overall you could tell that the courses had skill hidden behind the mistakes, but with only one of the four courses hitting the mark it was pretty disappointing. The bigger issue was that the whole meal felt disjointed as well. It fell like four different dishes that had just been forced into a single menu and there was no flow or continuity. In similar multi-course meals at Vora or Elderslie, there was a flow to each meal that helped the courses feel like one unified menu, and this felt more like someone had just liked these courses and wanted to serve them, so they got forced into a single menu.
For $200 by the end of the meal (though that did include cocktails which we enjoyed!) it just felt like a bit of a letdown. I don't mind paying for great multi-course meals (we paid more at both vora and elderslie), but this meal was definitely not worth the cost.