Gayle's Broadway Rose

We had an amazing experience at Gayle’s Broadway Rose! The atmosphere is so fun & the performers are excellent. I was especially excited to see Ben Diamond & Cara Rose DiPietro perform. The food is good and I love that they take reservations. We had Tori as a server and she was extremely attentive - and an amazing singer! Will definitely recommend to others and will be returning!

The interior of the restaurant is very appealing. However, the menu is quite expensive. Despite reserving a table in advance, we had to wait about 10 minutes to be seated upon arrival. The temperature inside was somewhat uncomfortable, being a bit too warm. Unfortunately, we were seated at a table near the window behind the bar, which didn't allow us to fully enjoy the experience, as most of the activity happens beyond the bar where there are more tables. The waitstaff were talented singers, which made it even more disappointing that we couldn't be seated in the main area to fully appreciate the atmosphere. The food was just okay. Our fries were overcooked and too spicy, so we didn't finish them. The buttermilk chicken sandwich was decent, but nothing special. The overall experience is much better when seated in the middle of the main room rather than at the bar or behind it. The service was pleasant, although the water was served neither cold nor with ice. Overall, I would rate it 3.5 stars out of 5.

Had an amazing time at Gayle's Broadway Rose! This place might not be for everyone, but if you are a lover of musical theater, this is the place for you! I wasn't sure if I wanted to go to Gayle's or Ellen's (another similar kind of restaurant) but ultimately chose Gayle's because reservations were easy to make and the food and atmosphere looked better in the reviews. The food was delicious! Menu was simple, not an overwhelming amount of options. And although some other reviews said they found the food expensive, I found it to be fairly priced for a restaurant in the Times Square vicinity. The 14 oz steak was huge! And the meatloaf was also a crowd favourite at my table. Gayle herself was there and introduced herself to every table. She was so nice and it seems like all the staff really got along and enjoyed their jobs. The talent of every single server truly blew me away. I felt like I was in an interactive Broadway show. Our server was Tommy. He was so nice and did an amazing rendition of Climb Every Mountain from The Sound Of Music. My family really enjoyed their time and would definitely recommend this place to anyone going to New York City!

I have a theater kid so we came for the Singing servers having no idea how the food was going to be. The menu is essentially comfort food and had very good flavors! Regarding the singing, it felt like a Non-stop show! Broadway songs sang by the servers and The servers have so much talent! We were celebrating a birthday and they came to our table and sang Happy birthday to the bday girl! She was so surprised and happy! If you like musical theater, this is a must in NYC. PS. I saw someone left a 1 star review because music was too loud. Really? If you don’t like loud music, don’t come. The purpose of this whole experience is the beautiful singing.

After a day of traveling to get to the city, this was the first place we went to! We were pretty hungry and enjoyed our food. Cocktails were really good too. Our serve was friendly, just like the host and other staff. I also really enjoyed the fact that our serve sang my favorite song from the Last 5 Years

Fun Dinner - great singers and decent food. Service can be a bit slow but the singing makes it all worth it.

The staff here is incredible!! They’re all so talented, I had a great time. I’m so glad I decided to check this place out after seeing it on tik tok. The food was good, service was speedy even though it was very crowded and they had to perform.

I would give 4.5 stars, because the waiters and singing were stellar. They really did a great job. The part that takes away from the experience is the feeling that they want you out quickly (i.e. the time limit sign and the hostess folk seem very rushed). We only had dessert ($20 milkshake and $10 cookie plate) and that was pretty good. I do like that they take reservations but it's not as fun to be seated by the bar - even though we had reservations we weren't seated in the main room.