Peter P.
Google
hatsu omakase is one of those nyc spots that feels like it runs on one thing and one thing only, reservations. you can tell the second you get there. if you show up early, you are not getting a cozy little corner inside. you are getting the sidewalk. outside seating. like you are waiting for a table at a brunch place, not about to eat sushi. it is a weird first impression, but whatever. this city loves making you earn dinner. once you are in, the vibe shifts. the staff was genuinely nice, not fake nice, not rushing you like you are an inconvenience. everyone did a great job. smooth service. good energy. you can feel that they are trying and i respect that. now the sushi is where it gets tricky, because hatsu is cheap, like considerably cheap compared to most omakase in the city, and that messes with your ability to judge it fairly. also my reservation was 9:30 pm, end of the day, end of the fish, end of the rhythm, so it is hard to assess quality when you are walking in that late and the price is doing half the talking. the format is simple. you get the main course, then you get four rounds of all you can eat that the restaurant chooses for you, and mine was salmon, fat tuna, yellowtail, and wagyu. the salmon during the main course was the highlight, it melted in your mouth like that clean soft bite that reminds you why people get emotional about sushi, but then the all you can eat salmon came out and it tasted different. not bad, different. it did not melt the same way and it tasted fishier, again not disgusting, just more real and less silky, and some pieces even had a little skin on them. and yeah, i passed one of those off to my girlfriend, love is patient, love is kind, love is letting her deal with the salmon skin. the rest of it held up fine, the fat tuna and yellowtail did what they were supposed to do, and the wagyu is wagyu, it is hard to mess up beef that rich. i did not drink, but there was an abundance of alcohol options and the pricing looked really solid, like they actually want you to order, not feel punished for it. my one petty gripe is the only soda they have is japanese soda, and i get it, it fits the theme, but sometimes you just want a regular coke or something normal, not a cute little bottle that tastes like nostalgia and bubblegum. overall hatsu omakase is a good deal with a few question marks that come with the territory. cheap omakase is always going to be a balancing act, especially late at night.