Daniel B.
Yelp
Herons was amazing. It lived up to the hype. This is one of my top two restaurants in the Triangle. The other is Fearrington House in Pittsboro. When it comes to fine dining, these are among the best in North Carolina. That said, they're expensive and not everyday restaurants. (For "everyday" restaurants in the Triangle, a couple of my top picks are M Sushi in Durham and Tesoro in Carrboro).
My wife preferred Herons to Fearrington House. For me, it's a push. She thought Herons had both better food and service. Food-wise, she thought the dishes at Herons were better composed and balanced. Service-wise, she felt the staff at Herons, from our bartender to the hostess to our server and the food runners, were warmer and provided more seamless service. Regardless, both places deliver exceptional dining experiences.
I've dined at six Michelin-star restaurants to date (I'm not saying that to humble-brag, I'm saying it to give context) and I think Herons is Michelin-star quality. It's on that level. When the Michelin Guide hit Atlanta in 2023, I correctly predicted several of the restaurants that got stars. While the Michelin Guide hasn't covered North Carolina yet, Herons still has impressive accolades. I saw 2024 Forbes Travel Guide Five Stars and 2020 AAA Five Diamond awards during our visit.
Herons is located inside the Umstead Hotel and Spa, a luxury hotel and spa situated just off I-40 exit 287 (Harrison Ave). For parking, you can use the hotel valet or self-park for free in the dedicated lot off Woodland Pond Dr.
Use OpenTable to book your reservation. Unlike Fearrington House, which I also booked via OpenTable, Herons awarded dining points. I used OpenTable's messaging system to communicate with Herons staff and make a change to our reservation. It worked well.
Herons serves breakfast, brunch, lunch, and dinner. My wife and I had a 7pm reservation on a Saturday. We showed up early and had drinks at the Umstead's Bar & Lounge. It was really nice (the entire property was) and set the tone for what turned into a magnificent evening. The Bar & Lounge was busy before and after our dinner. The Umstead is a happening place.
For dinner, we went with Herons' standard four-course prix fixe dinner at $170 per person. For comparison, four courses at Fearrington House was $150 per person. Both offer $100 drink/wine pairings and supplements for certain courses. Both also offer more elaborate tasting menus. At Herons, it's the "Art Tour," consisting of 8-15 courses at $250 per person.
We got to choose from 4-5 selections for each course. My wife and I chose different things for each course so we could try many dishes. Here's what we got:
Cocktails
* Lilac ($16) - Cathead vodka, creme de violette, blueberry, lychee, yuzu
* Ruby cocktail ($16) - Lunazul Reposado, rhubarb, One Oak Farm beets, citrus
Non-Alcoholic Infusions
* Drinking Vinegars - Strawberry-Basil ($8)
Before First
* English pea macarons with creme fraiche and Siberian caviar
* Buckwheat baguettes and butter from Marietta, Georgia
First
* Oyster - poached, Charleston Gold Rice, Champagne Sabayon
* Wagyu - asparagus, egg sauce, finger lime, kosho, sauce Japonaise
Before Second
* Chef's play on bacon, eggs and toast; quail eggs, bacon mousse, edible nest
* Chive croissants with garlic butter
Second
* Egg - 62-degree egg, One Oak grits, mushroom, Iberico ham, shrimp.
* Foie Gras ($20 supplement) - strawberries, sudachi, salted Marcona almond creme; Carolina pineberries
Before Entrees
* Duck confit corn dogs, made to look like cattails
* Milk bread with honey butter
Entrees
* Tuna - ossetra, miso, chive, Meyer lemon, brown butter dashi
* Beef - two styles (strip steak and short rib), farm carrots, sea buckthorn puree, Shaoxing sauce
Before Dessert
* Elderflower pickled rhubarb, lime (and other ingredients I forgot)
* French press decaf coffee (large, $9)
Dessert
* Honey - milk ganache, kataifi, orange blossom, nitro labneh, bee pollen
* Cheese - Fromager d'Affinois espuma, air baguette, mostarda, English peas
After Dessert Gifts
* Dark chocolate, yuzu gummies with blueberry centers, housemade Red Hots, and caramels
The four-course was an "art tour" itself. It was truly a culinary adventure with neat surprises along the way. And for those wondering, we left the restaurant completely stuffed. The timing and attention to detail was almost impeccable. For example, the butters that accompanied the bread courses were consistently themed. The garlic butter that came with the croissants looked like leaves and the honey butter that came with the milk bread looked like honeycomb. The quail eggs in the edible nest and the duck confit corn dog cattails were creative and fun. The 62-degree egg was served in/with wooden bowls and a wooden spoon rest made from fallen trees on the property. The dishes were unique and the flavors and textures were superb.
The entire Herons and Umstead staff were terrific, including our fantastic server Mike.