Joe C.
Yelp
Another anniversary, and it's always my job to pick the place... I try and pick a place that will give us a different experience than we can replicate at home. I can probably select and grill a steak better than most steakhouses.
I left things a little last-second this year, which ruled out a few options. And my wife is gluten-free, which rules out a few more. So I thought about Hudson's.
I called the evening before to check into the menu. My first call went to the answering machine. By the time I called back, it was pretty much closing time. However, this time, Sara answered the phone. I explained our needs, and she very patiently went through the menu, saying what substitutions could be made for my wife, what could not be made gluten free, and what was safe without modification. She was very patient with my possibly dumb questions. Turns out, that was the restaurant manager, and co-author of one of their books, who didn't seem to mind my inane 15 minute call for a party of two. Reservation secured.
Now, it's a good trek out there, esp. on a work night, which makes it harder to "surprise" the wife. Now, for what can be a pricy meal, the dress code, as confirmed by "Sara", is not fancy. Folks in business suits can be next to kids dressed for prom, next to a couple in jeans. Even moreso than your average Austin venue. But being underdressed always stresses out my wife. I was hoping to just go in our work clothes, but she quickly jumped into jeans because she didn't know I actually had anything booked (sometimes we wait for the weekend). I did convince her to switch back to "business casual". Good call, for her comfort's sake. That's just her thing.
If I could remove 1/4 of a star, it would be for the parking lot. If you're not lucky, it involves a climb up a hill, and I'm not a fan of leaving my wife at the door while I fetch a car because I don't want her turning an ankle in the dark. But, "country charm", and whatnot.
The greeter was friendly as can be. We were seated immediately at a quiet corner table near the fireplace (but not right in front of it). This isn't the most romantic place in the world, if you're into booths and privacy. But it's obvious we were put in that table on purpose. The waitress was again very patient with our questions, confirmed a couple things with the kitchen, and worked a couple wine options for us.
We went all out, apps first. The "Pumpkin risotto with fresh Maine lobster and maple glazed pumpkin" was ok, but really cooled (too?) quickly. And we decided maybe we just don't "get" risotto. Do folks love it because they know it's so hard to get right? To me, a fairly decent risotto is often only slightly better than a good rice-a-roni. But I REALLY love a good rice-a-roni! The "Coca Cola baby back ribs with chipotle BBQ sauce and mango jalapeno cole slaw": home run, tender and tasty.
The wife chose the "Pecan smoked duck breast shingled with seared diver scallops nestled in wild boar sweet potato hash and a cranberry chipotle sauce". Another home run. The sweet potato hash was unreal. Probably her favorite part of the night. No knock on the duck, which had just the right amount of smoke. I did the "man" thing, and got the "mixed grill". The venison, quail, and buffalo were amazing. The sausage was "ok", and the rabbit tenders: eh. But it was fun to try so many different things...
We were pretty full when the discussion of dessert came around. I did feel like we were being slightly pressured to order something, and later found out why. To be fair, they had way more choices than the usual gluten free options we hear at other places: "We have sorbet". Yeah, thanks. My wife was intrigued by the Meyer lemon panna cotta from one of the tasting menus. Being part of a tasting, it's not as large as one from the regular dessert menu. Which was really just fine for us. I expected not to be able to get it, but they didn't give us grief about it being from the tasting menu. Then when it arrived, we saw the plate it was set on had "Happy Anniversary" written in chocolate, which was obviously only because of a note made on our reservation. Nice touch.
All in all, a really pleasant experience: 2+ unrushed hours. Per Sara's advice the day before, they did happily accept a restaurant.com (yes, I'm "that guy")coupon (and slightly bent the rules to our benefit), which made it insanely cheap (for what it was). So, even on the pre-discount price, the server got a pretty good tip. We left both commenting that it just seemed that everyone front of house seemed to enjoy their job, and, even if it was just acting, seemed concerned with the dining experience.
Service: 5*
Food: 4 1/2*
Parking lot: 3*
Overall: 4+*
Cheers to Sara, et al.