Ben E.
Yelp
It's almost criminal that, at 8 pm on a Saturday night, La Encantada is practically empty. Well...actually entirely empty until I walked in. Considering the quality of the food and service here, it's astounding.
I ordered the quesadilla with huitlacoche as a starter, which was served with fresh salsa and a dollop of excellent crema. Based on lots of recommendations via Yelp and elsewhere, I also ordered the Chile en Nogada, although I rarely like that kind of sweet and savory combination. After this, I'll have to reconsider my aversion. The poblano pepper was stuffed with an extremely flavorful and complex mixture of spicy ground beef, raisins, cashews, almonds, and bits of apple and pear. The "creamy nut sauce" is sweet but not overwhelmingly so, and is sprinkled with pomegranate seeds. This is truly gourmet quality food at an extremely low price.
All main courses come with your choice of a side salad, rice, or beans, as well as a side dish. I ordered the nopales, which were a nice complement to the richness of the Chile en Nogada. The other sides looked excellent as well.
As for drinks, I couldn't resist trying El Diablito, comprised of tequila, lime juice, a splash of soda water, and chile powder. I certainly intend to try their margaritas, and it's good to see that they serve micheladas, but I'm willing to bet I'll be back specifically for El Diablito whether I'm ordering dinner or not.
Finally, if you're a fan of huitlacoche, as I am, this is one of the few restaurants I've seen that make a real effort to feature this ingredient in a variety of styles and preparations. That alone is a major reason to go several times over.
This is a warm, friendly, cool place. It really deserves a much, much wider audience. Sure, it's nice to have La Encantada all to oneself, but I'd be happier to wait for a table and see the owners succeed in bringing great Mexican cuisine to Humboldt Park.