Dan M.
Yelp
Fun new spot worth a visit. The design of the space is amazing, with long open windows providing fresh air, and tons of seating. There are bar seats, tables, stools for window seating, and a few tables outside. The lights were down low, and the beats were popping, so a nice mood was set immediately. We visited around 9:00 pm on a Saturday. The place had lots of life, but there were still plenty of open seats available, no reservations needed.
They are sister establishments with the pizza place next door, Slice & Pie, and you can order pizza at Lucy. Pizza and cocktails are an unbeatable combination you don't see often enough.
For drinks, they are known for their frozen pina coladas and orange crushes, but they have lots of unique cocktails available. Their focus is twists on classics. My wife had a black magic, which is an old fashioned variation with a hint of allspice and saffron. She really enjoyed it. It came out looking deep purple and tasted boozy and delicious. The cin cyn is a negroni riff with cynar and grapefruit bitters. Very refreshing if you're a fan of bitter drinks. After eating, we shared an espresso martini as well, and their take is one of the best in town. It is definitely different than any other espresso martini you'll find, which we appreciated. It has salted agave and "mole spices," which give it a very slight cinnamony taste. Yummy. The drinks are priced from $11-14 apiece. There are a few draft beers and tons of wines by the glass or bottle available as well, if that's your thing.
What puts them over the top is the food. Their garlic knots are crisp on the outside but soft on the inside, super fresh. Don't skip them. We also shared a pizza, the 'roni ($16). It came with four large slices of thin crust pizza with crsip, thick crust. It was a good portion for sharing - we split the knots and pizza and were both full when we were done. The pizza is solid, good amount of pepperoni, and a perfect pairing with the cocktails. The menu has lots of red and white options to choose from. It seems like we've become spoiled with new pizza options the past couple years, between Martha Dear, Sonnys, Lupo Pizzeria, the thin crust options are through the roof, and Lucy's take is on par with these others.
The only negative remark we have is about service. The first guy to serve us, the guy with a pony tail and glasses, was super sweet and attentive. About halfway through our meal, though, he left, and his replacement was terrible. He didn't pay attention to anyone at the bar despite it not being busy. We had to flag him down to order, and he made a show of how annoyed he was to have to serve us, and we weren't the only ones who got that treatment. That issue aside, we had a nice time and will try them again.