Made In New York Pizza

I’ve been coming here for years whenever I am on the Upper West Side or wanting to have pizza in the park. It was one of my favorite pizza places in the city. There are several different pizza places with the same name and signage as this one on 80th and Amsterdam but I believe this is the best. It is a very standard pizza place with usually plenty of seating. I’d say it can be very hot inside the restaurant on a hot day. Always look for the pies that look like they have been made recently as they typically taste the best. I can’t recommend this place more and can’t wait to go back.

Pretty solid slice shop on the west side! Maybe a little inconsistent in terms of crispness of the crust - my first slice was absolutely perfect but the second one could have done with a bit more time in the oven. Lots of cheese and pretty good toppings though. I’d come back.

Very good pizza!! Cheese is tasty, very good toppings, crispy and fresh crust. Highly recommended

Every pizza tastes fantastic here! My favourite are the vodka and the one with artichokes!

Most delicious pizza in New York. I loved the vodka sauce slice and pepperoni slices. The dough is cooked to perfection. The service is also great the staff are all friendly and welcoming with quick service and great prices. Thank you for a delicious meal, can’t wait to go back again.

The pizza is great, we also tried the garlic bread. but the server is not as friendly when my friend ask about the ingredients (she have dietary restrictions). However other than that, they serve a good pizza. And also the place is quite spacy and you can sit in it, in which not all pizza place has a lot of space to sit.

Great taste, quality is there and staff give warm vibes as well. Normally pepperoni is my favorite, took staff recommendation and also tried vodka slice- hard to tell which was better. Try this spot!

We tried two pizza by the slice places while we were in NYC and this one was definitely the better option. It was recommended by one of the locals and she sure knew what she was talking about. Customer service was a bit non-existent but the food PHENOMENAL. The pizza by the slice ranged from $3.50-$5.50. We tried the white pizza with ricotta (delicious), the classic pepperoni 🍕 (my favorite), and the pepperoni mushroom (my son's favorite). All three were delicious. The flavor profiles were good and the tomato based sauce was fire 🔥 If I'm ever back in the big city, this is definitely on my need-to-stop-in list of places. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5 Star ingredients means 5 star food. SOOO delicious

Hands down one of THE best slices in NYC! Perfect balance of cheese and sauce on a solid crust. Their eggplant pizza was a game changer! And as for the grand ma I go outta my way whenever I'm on the UWS to get one because it's just soooo dang delicious!

It's true what they say. NY pizza destroys all others. Yes, that includes you all, my fellow Chicago faithful. Chicago tavern pizza is absolute trash. It's gotta be the sweet sweet Hudson River water that makes it so good. Haven't lived in NYC for 20 years, but to my memory, this is the best NY slice that I've had anywhere else in the city. Even the Diet Coke was better than usual.

Good pizza. Fast service. Friendly people. They have indoor and outdoor seating areas, too, with that great NYC pizza parlor ambiance, so this is a good option when you want to sit and mingle. They offer such fast service that it's also a great option when you just want to grab and go and eat a slice while you walk.

Very good pizza. It's a casual place and they also have outdoor seating. I really enjoyed my meal. They also sell alcoholic beverages.

I'm obsessed with NY Slice Pizza! Not only did I enjoy their deliciously slices with the perfect balance of cheese and sauce, but I also received top-notch service! The staff were friendly, attentive, and made sure my experience was nothing short of fantastic. The pizza is truly exceptional - no flop, just a beautifully cooked crust. I'm so impressed with this NYC-style pizza joint, and I can't recommend it enough. The combination of mouthwatering pizza and excellent service.

This is the spot when you want a late night slice of pizza or even the whole pie ! We came here around 2pm and it was busy but the service was great, we got our pizza super fast and it was heated in the big oven. You must get the classic style with cheese and pepperoni! It was delicious! Definitely recommend!

Five stars. Impeccable service--we ordered by phone for pickup late last night around 11:30. They told us 15 minutes. We were a three minute walk--they had the pizza fresh and hot and perfectly cooked in 12 min. Perfect New York Style dough mix between a crispy, dark brown exterior and a nice little chew to the dough with bubbles on the crust. Delicious brightness to the tomato sauce and delectable cheese. Not overpriced and well seasoned. I expected to eat two slices and ended up eating six.

Great grandma slices! The favorite today was the veggie with peppers, onions and mushrooms. The upside down was okay. Might have been better if we had eaten it right out of the oven. Tried the garlic knots (5 for $4). They very large, greasy, garlicky; overall good! NOTE: there is a service charge if you pay by credit card

Nasty & Rude Service for an +$100 order. Literally throws change and receipt across counter. If you don't like your job, make a change. Service, at minimum should be courteous and kind. Unpleasant and ill- mannered. You are why tips should be adjustable for 24 hours.

Pretty fast service with delicious pizza! Be warned the pizza is extremely oily and heavy, but super yummy! Highly recommend the vodka as well as the spicy pepperoni.

So delicious!! Service was so pleasing! Food was a perfect serving . Will try a dish again .

This joint embodies what an out-of-towner like myself envisions a NYC pizza parlor should be. Big selection of pizzas by the slice served up quick and hot with a gruff but polite manager (who bears a resemblance to actor John Carroll Lynch) moving things along. The slices were the best we had on this trip--big and foldable with a hot crisp bottom. The real winner, however, was the eggplant Sicilian. Thick buttery crust with nice tender eggplant slices buttressed by mozzarella and a killer red sauce. If it were only hot in the middle, this would be a 5 star review. The dining room is small but serviceable and tables cleared pretty quickly with what appeared to be mostly locals dining there. A nice place to stop after an afternoon at the Museum of Natural History (a few blocks away). (4.5 stars).

Wow!! One of the best slices of pizza I've had in the city. The sauce really made it. It tastes so fresh and handmade. The eggplant was so soft you could bite right into it. The crust was thick and so so good. A great slice! Unfortunately the indoor seating was not air conditioned and I went on a scorching evening. So we had to sit outside which also was very hot.

10/10 Food was yum! We went around 10pm and to be almost closing time it was very busy. I'd definitely come back if i'm in the area.

no me gusto la pizza, tiene mal sabor. no hace la pizaa al horno de una vez la hacen para que se quede horas esperado

One of the better pizza options I've had in manhattan so far! Highly recommend checking out, fast service and good slice of pizza for the price!

Came in because of the great reviews but personally I don't think they're any better or different from other pizza spots that I've checked out. I do like that they have many slice options for you to choose from from both square and regular pies. Also they're generous with the slice portion and toppings. Our BBQ Chicken and Grandma slices were VERY well-toasted in the oven like seriously it burnt the roof of our mouth. Very hot so do be cautious. But that did give the slices a nice, crunchy base and gooey cheese.

Yummy, easy, convenient pizza spot! We called ahead and went to pay and pick it up there. We got a deeper dish pepperoni and a white sauce garlic one - both delicious, but I preferred the pepperoni. The shop is pretty small but still has a few tables inside and some cocktail tables outside. Was a great bite while in NYC!

Pretty solid slice of New York pizza. Oily pepperoni and nondroopy crust. The musts for a ny slice. Stopped by for a quick slide after spending the afternoon at Central Park. Good spot for a quick in and out.

One more Vodka pizza for the road.... NYC, it's been great! They're your tastebuds! Satisfy them!

My favorite pizza place in New York so far!!! My favorite is the spicy pepperoni square. The dough is so crispy and fresh. The cups are oozing with oil. The service was great! It was so fast to get my food. I always take people who are visiting me to this place!

My "go to" late night pizza. Live stopping here on the way home from the theater. Good NY pizza and there's always a nice selection late night. Super crisp crust and cooked perfectly. The service is also great. Staff are all friendly and welcoming with quick service. Great prices too

This place was pretty good. Would recommend. The food was great, the service wasn't slow, and it was nice.

Amazing NY pizza perfect in all aspects, better that flatbread pizza in Hawaii, it checks all the list for a perfect classic pizza

My pizza here was really good. I love this type of pepperoni on my pizza and wish all pizza shops would serve them. My pizza came out hot, crispy and cheesy. I really like the style of the pizza it reminded me of a grandma slice. The customer service was pretty good and the prices were ok. I would visit again if I were in the area and I may be because I visit the Trader Joe's frequently. Anyway thumbs up for me. Happy Yelping!

Good choice for a late-night slice! The crust was crunchy and twice baked. Not a ton of pepperonis on the meat lovers slice. Not sure the slices were worth $5.50 but if you're hungry and it's what's open then I'd go for it! We went right before closing at 10:45pm so I'd assume had we gone earlier, our experience may have been a little different with some fresher slices! Service was decent - and in regard to ambiance, there isn't any haha

Pizza not served hot at all. Don't know why they bother to put it in the oven I should have gone to Prince street pizza . It wasn't terrible but it wasn't close to the hype it gets. Good dough. Pepperoni wasn't spicy enough. Staff were trying to clean up and split. Does not matter if your open your open. Serve the pizza properly.

Exactly what the name says. Fast, delicious New York style pizza. Price was good too!

Delicious slices all around. Classic and solid choice for a slice. The crust was crunchy and the slices weren't too saucy. I really enjoyed the vodka sauce slice. Great staff and plenty of seating inside and outside.

Actual rating: 3.5 Our last pizza of the trip, and while much much better than the 99 cent pizza, it still doesn't really compare to joes pizza and scarrs. For me, this place belongs in the middle, and as a late night craving, really does hit the spot.

The pizza is fine, the business practices albeit a bit shady. They offer a free slice if you show your 5 star review (note that it has to be 5 stars). Not sure how many of the five star reviews on here are legitimate or not, but what I will say is that it's hardly truly excellent pizza. A tad overpriced as well even compared to the norm in the neighborhood. They always have a ton of options available. Specialty slices are large but will run you a hefty $6 for a single slice. Cheese I believe is $3.50 or so. Usually only a couple of the available options will be "fresh" and everything else needs a solid reheating in the oven. Their grandma slices are way more bread than anything else. With that said, I actually like this place better than Saba's, Ray's, and Marinara's, so I'll probably be back. Freddie and Pepper's is better but not as convenient for me.

I'm always looking for pizza when in NYC and this spot was one of my stops on my last trip. I got a Spicy Pepperoni Square. They use the good pepperoni that forms the little cups which I love. It was a solid slice of pizza. One thing I didn't like is that they give you a free piece of pizza if you leave a 5 star review for them which means you can't trust their reviews.

Menu on line is not updated. I was overcharged by $2. Tasty enough pizza but is a "cheesy business". Count your change. Also if u don't pay cash, charge is 3.95% higher. Would never go back out of principal.

Solid spot for when you're out in the UWS and need a quick pick-me-up. I ordered the eggplant parm square and my friend ordered a BBQ chicken slice. The square was really tasty - perfectly cooked eggplant (which is hard to do) and a good sauce that wasn't too sweet or salty. Our food came out within 5 minutes and the two slices set us back about $11. I will say, maybe avoid going around 3pm on a weekday because it'll likely be full of kids who just got out of school.

A spectacular NYC style pie. One of the best pizzas on the upper west side. Top 10 in Manhattan. I am shocked by how much I enjoy it.

As good a square slice in any combination as you can buy in Manhattan. Crisp crust with a great crunch and a hint of char. Pillowy but never raw on top. Outstanding quality tomato, sauce and cheese. Roasted peppers, mushrooms, and onions on the veggie slice are absolutely outstanding. Plain slices are as good as any around. This place is the real deal.

Tasty variety here. I enjoyed both sliced. The eggplant looked and did taste so good. Tons of marinara. The eggplant was surprisingly good too, usually don't care for those. The crest is yummy. The pepperoni mushroom was a loooong piece and really good. They heat it up right before handing to you. Nice seating inside. Efficient line to get people moving, could be a little more kind or happy, they seemed bothered when I asked what they'd recommend to eat for my first time.

A review is a review, a pizza slice is a pizza slice. When I saw somebody stopped in and gave it praise, I had to stop at this Upper West Side pizza shop and compare. For this review I ate five slices. For you judgmental folk, I had absolutely no lunch today, this makes up for that. Forgive me for being a pig for eating a lot of pizza. Each slice will be scored on a five point scale. If you really to go ten points, double my score. "One bite, everyone knows the rules." Oh wait, that is how someone else operates. This is how I operate. Plain triangle slice: Slightly sweet sauce, with a bit of tang. Crispy crust, nice cheese, hot out of the oven. Solid slice, but I do not think it is memorable. Once I finished it, I moved on to the other slices in my box. Score: 3.7 White Square: A white square? Seriously? Yes, but it works. A thin layer of cheese, but a nice layer of garlic. Good flavor, lovely crust, easy to get carried away with this. Personally I prefer a white round, but I can respect this take on a true classic. Score: 3.8 Upside Down Square: Pretty solid slice. The sauce dominates this square, the cheese is almost forgotten. You will need to go through a tree's worth of napkins just to get through this one. With a crispy crust, a sweet sauce, and a small hint of cheese, better get a drink or you will be sorry! Score: 3.6 Spicy Pepperoni Square: This is the most memorable of all the slices I ate. The spicy pepperoni packs a strong punch, and you get some in each bite. Order a cup of water to temper it, and use your drink judiciously so you can this with ease. While it is no Prince Street Pizza or Paulie Gee's, this one can get your fill adequately without going to Nolita or Brooklyn. Score: 4.1 Grandma Square: Classic Grandma has nice flavor. Eat it with the basil to get some color and some green in your pállate. The crust is a bit thin, but it has excellent crunch. It could use more cheese, instead that sauce just dominated the entire square. Seems like a running theme here, you know? Score: 3.8 -- I would also like to point something out. When I asked for a cup of water, the person behind the counter gave me a plastic cup and then literally observed me as I put water in from the dispenser. As if he thought I would bilk him out of a soft drink. Not cool. Sometimes you have to trust people, especially one who just gave you $26 worth of business. I also was not appreciative of the woman behind the counter who scoffed at me when I asked if the restaurant recycles. It is a fair question to ask! Other than that, the pizza is generally pretty good. If someone asks me about it, I can recommend it. Hopefully you will be more selective than my five slices... or not.

My order arrived a some 50 minutes late, inedible due to being soggy and cold. To make matters worse, your complete disregard for customer service is appalling. I called repeatedly at the provided numbers: +1 (646) 484-6200, (234) 235-6584, and (888) 974-9928, only to be ignored. In other words, thanks , but no thanks! There are plenty of other alternatives that can provide on-time, high-quality food with proper customer support, and I will be taking my business elsewhere.

Great pizza place to grab a quick slice in the upper west side. This is what you think of when you think NYC style pizza! Had slices of cheese, pepperoni, margarita, and even a square piece of spicy pepperoni... all delicious!!

Great pizza, fast, friendly. We got 2 slices, but whole pie are available of course. The place was busy and just a little warm to sit in, but as people left, it cooled off a bit. We had the upside down slice, which reminded my wife of her dad's sauce...that's a good thing. We also had a margherita slice and it was thin and the basil was very fresh. We definitely would come here again if we lived in town!

The spicy pepperoni pizza is incredible. My go to slice nearby. The buffalo chicken wasn't my favorite but the grandma is also good. Quick service and plenty of seating. Will definitely be frequenting this place!

My daughter and I were in NYC for the Central Park Philharmonic concert. We were walking around and sampling different food before the show. We already had some Chinese food and I knew that I wanted to try Made in New York Pizza. My daughter told me we should do a taste test vs another local pizzeria she likes. I was game and our timing was good, we were able to walk right up to the counter. My daughter got a margarita slice and I got a white square slice. Right off the jump (first bite) I knew I was in for something really good. The texture is light but still bringing the necessary chew. The white pie flavor was perfectly savory and cheesy. My daughter enjoyed her margarita enough that we canceled out the taste test and I went back up to the counter for two more slices. The gentleman working the counter recommended the spicy pepperoni square and I added a vodka slice. The vodka slice was delicious but the spicy pepperoni was fantastic! I believe it's neck and neck with another famous square pepperoni slice. This one had the perfect pizza base and the pepperoni itself was a really pleasant texture. I'll definitely be back for more. Nice seating area, good and quick service. Can definitely see why the reviews are so good.

By far the best pizza I have EVER had in my entire existence. This was the third pizza spot we tried when visiting New York and this one BLEW ME AWAY. We got the vodka pizza and it did not disappoint. I definitely will be dreaming about this pizza for the next few months

Awesome pizza! Honestly, this was some of the best pizza I've ever had. It's a no fuss kind of place but the prices are reasonable (for NYC anyway) and they have outdoor seating. We'll definitely be back in our next visit to the city.

Dave Portnoy said in his YouTube video that Prince St was suing this place for stealing their recipe. That was 3 years ago so maybe they changed the recipe because the spicy pepperoni was not the same as Prince St. The most obvious difference was that there did not seem to be any hot honey oil. The pepperoni cups were very similar as well as the dough, but without the hot honey oil, it was just way too one dimensionally salty. Also, if you are paying with cash, make sure you get the CASH DISCOUNT. The pie was listed on the menu board at $34 and with tax, they charged $37.02, which I paid with cash. I did not realize I did not get the discount until we got back to the car and my wife asked me about it, and by that time, it was not worth it to walk back all those blocks. So this place left a bad taste in my mouth both literally and figuratively.

My experience at maiden New York pizza has always been a good one. They serve great slices for a great price but also amazing service

Pizza is nothing special. We got the spicy pepperoni which was a little on the salty side for me. Not sure what the abundance of 5 star reviews are for. The previous review where the person mentioned a free slice for a 5 star review, if true, makes the high Yelp rating questionable. Also the discount for cash sign should be taken off as they charged us the same amount as listed. I would have given a higher rating if I hadn't been expecting to be blown away...also if they had honored the cash discount, it is dishonest to claim to give a cash discount to justify charging for credit card use.

MiNY is a solid place to grab a slice. It's not destination pizza; it's a neighborhood spot. I wouldn't take a train for it, but I would cross a couple streets. The most unusual variety is probably the sausage and jalapeño. It tastes roughly how you would expect. The jalapeño is pickled and adds a tang, as well as some heat. I actually enjoyed the penne vodka slice as well (which i guess is the 2022 pizza trend). Ultimately, you'll pay a fair price, wait a short time in line, and end up with a decent NY style pizza.