Marabella Pizza

Pizza restaurant · Sunnyside

Marabella Pizza

Pizza restaurant · Sunnyside

4107 Greenpoint Ave, Sunnyside, NY 11104

Highlights

Neighborhood pizzeria since 1984 providing thin-crust pies & casual Italian staples, plus delivery.

4107 Greenpoint Ave, Sunnyside, NY 11104 Get directions

marabellapizzamenu.com

@marabellaspizza

@eater

"Debuting in 1984 and occupying a distinctive corner location in Sunnyside, Marabella is proud of its Sicilian roots, as evidenced by the choice of art and maps on the walls. The ovens stand right inside the front door to make it easy to dash in and out for a slice. You should look no further than the fine grandma slice, which is square and thin-crusted, sporting fresh mozzarella and thick, sweet tomato sauce. Unique to Marabella are sandwiches (the pizzeria calls focaccia) made by splitting a thick wedge of pizza and piling it with chicken Parm and other fillings." - Robert Sietsema

The Giant Eater Map of New York City Slices

View Postcard for Marabella Pizza

@eater

"Located on Sunnyside’s hopping Greenpoint Avenue, Marabella turns out a bewildering variety of pizzas, sandwiches, and seafood dishes. But walk in and you’re likely to spot in a glass display case its proudest invention: a chicken parm sandwich on two slices of focaccia. You can eat this wonderful sandwich like you eat a slice of pizza." - Robert Sietsema

Eater Critic Robert Sietsema Ranks His 11 Favorite Hot Parm Heros - Eater NY

View Postcard for Marabella Pizza

@eater

"I finally found something similar at Marabella, a pizza-shaped premises on Greenpoint Avenue in Sunnyside. This rollicking neighborhood spot decorated with maps of Sicily offers the usual assortment of slices, pastas, and sandwiches, but one displayed in a glass case on the counter caught my eye. These were wedge-shaped sandwiches that seemed to be made with two slices of pizza. The slices were really a tomato-smeared focaccia cut in half horizontally and then further cut into wedges, but damned if they didn’t look like slices of pizza. The effect was nearly the same. The filling was breaded chicken cutlets with cheese melted on top, and arugula and tomato completed the illusion that it was a sandwich made with two slices of pizza. The sandwich ($7), called a focaccia chicken cutlet sandwich, was popped in the oven and heated up — tomato, arugula, and all — before arriving to me on a white paper plate. The thing tasted great: The annealed tomato sauce and a bonus tomato wedge on top contributed lots of flavor and moisture, while the chicken cutlet retained its crunch even under a mantle of cheese." - Robert Sietsema

Sunnyside Pizza Shop Marabella Serves a Delicious Focaccia Chicken Sandwich - Eater NY

View Postcard for Marabella Pizza

Peter S

Google

I got the most rotten chicken cutlets you could imagine from here the other day. Biting into them the cheese tasted sour, and the chicken had a yellow tinge to it. The chicken was extremely tough, and tasted old. Will not order from here ever again!

Marchia Velliano

Google

A great neighborhood pizzeria. The food quality is generally superb but not without inconsistency. I almost feel like there are two shifts in the premise; say, Team A and Team B. When Team A is on duty, the pizza tastes excellent, whereas Team B bakes salty and bland pizza. I think they need to hash out why that is.

D I

Google

I wanted to like this place more, it was clean, including the available bathroom, and the manager was pleasant and professional. But: one of the two pizza pies was very undercooked, the other one was somewhat better; but it feels like they skimp on the sauce and the cheese. Also, avoid the cheese cake at all costs.

D J

Google

Please do better. This is the soggiest and most oily pizza I've ever received. The crust basically had no structure and the pizza was falling apart. I was even more annoyed to find that we were not given any napkins, yet the worker asked the next customer in line if they wanted napkins. If you're going to give such oily pizza, at least provide napkins.

Kaye

Google

They only have one size pizza which is large. I got a large cheese pizza with extra cheese and it cost $20. They have a cooler inside bottled soda's to drink. The pizza tasted really delicious. If you want cups of marinara it is a dollar per small cup. The server was friendly. The place was clean inside. I recommend ordering from this pizza Restaurant.

Lin Htoo Aung

Google

I got there for my family dinner like Sicilian authentic pizzas. I took a special Sicilian one that included paparonni, mushrooms, pork sausages, and so on. It is really big and delicious for the whole family. And it cost me only 35$ with a coke. I recommend it 👍.

R&R Recovery

Google

This is my childhood pizza shop. I would stop in for a slice of pizza on my way home from school. We would order it at home it was just the best. I'm coming home for a visit and definitely stopping in for pizza and knots!

Diana Esquivel

Google

I love this pizza place! The pizza is really good and the guys that work there are very nice! Really good customer service! A gentleman who seems like the owner takes the time to handle candy to kids in Halloween and I think that’s very sweet and gives this place extra points :)