Alan B.
Yelp
A good location and very popular spot. They provide complimentary valet parking. There are many positives here, and a few negatives. Let's begin with the positives:
+ Good location
+ Water views from many tables
+ Outside seating with some shade
+ Dogs allowed in certain areas
+ Prompt service
+ Food was pretty good overall
And a few minuses:
- Very busy, crowded
- Very small restroom, one sink (3 people were waiting in this tiny rest room to wash their hands)
- Numerous large groups
- Calamari was just okay, limp with an oily texture
- Waitress said our gift card couldn't include the tip, she wouldn't be compensated (that was annoying!)
We ordered:
PT. JUDITH CALAMARI - lightly fried, cherry peppers, arugula,
capers, citrus aioli. 15.95
LOBSTER ROLL - chilled lobster meat, lightly dressed
with mayonnaise, chopped celery, grilled buttery roll. 28.95
POTTER POND POKE BOWL - yellowfin tuna,
edamame, peppers, seaweed, avocado, carrot, cucumber, crispy
wontons, sticky rice, sesame tamari, ginger aioli. 24.95
And a Sparkling Water and an Ice Tea.
I liked the Poke Bowl, the ingredients were fresh, the tuna tasty and it was a substantial dish. The Lobster Roll was good, it was very lightly dressed my co-diner thought there should have been a little more dressing. She said it was good, but certainly not in her top 3. The fries were good, hot and quite crisp. And the Calamari, as mentioned previously, was somewhat limp with an oily texture, though still reasonably tasty. It was a large portion, which was not finished.
Overall, I can see why there are many good reviews for this restaurant, and thought this merited a 3-star rating for this visit, because of the calamari and the gift card issue.