Mia's Brooklyn Bakery

I’ve only tried their coffee so far. The flavor is really good — smooth and well-balanced. The space is cozy and the vibe is nice.. The only thing I found a bit strange is that the coffee wasn’t hot enough. It was warm, but not as hot as I would expect. If they could serve it a little hotter, it would be perfect. Overall, still a solid spot for coffee and I would come back.

Mia’s Bakery is hands down one of the best bakeries in Brooklyn. Everything here is consistently delicious, from the cakes to the individual dessert slices. I ordered a custom Grinch cake for my holiday Christmas party and it was a huge hit — not only was it adorable, but it tasted amazing too. Super moist, flavorful, and not overly sweet. I also have to shout out their chocolate mousse cake slice because it is absolute perfection. Rich, smooth, and indulgent without being heavy — I crave it regularly. If you’re looking for a bakery that delivers both on presentation and flavor, this is the spot. Highly recommend for special occasions or just treating yourself.

I had an absolutely wonderful experience at Mia’s Brooklyn Bakery. Their cheesecakes are seriously incredible — the rich, velvety New York‑style cheesecake was a highlight. On top of the amazing desserts, our server was a delight: warm, attentive, and really made the visit feel special. We got lucky and they sat our large party even though we arrived shortly before closing. That was such a generous touch, and it made the evening feel relaxed and welcoming. The dessert selection overall was fantastic — everything tasted fresh and delicious. I highly recommend Mia’s Brooklyn Bakery to anyone looking for a classic, high‑quality bakery experience with top-tier cheesecakes and a friendly, laid‑back atmosphere.

Mia’s bakery was amazing they were able to take my last minute order and they executed on the design of the cake. The taste and look of the cake was the talk of the night. If you are looking for a tasty dessert custom cake for your next event you should definitely go with Mia’s Bakery, I will using them for future events!

“I have placed three cake orders with them so far—two of which were fully customized—and they executed every detail with complete accuracy. Each design turned out exactly as I envisioned, and the quality exceeded my expectations every time. The staff at the store were incredibly helpful, kind, and professional throughout the entire process. They took the time to answer my questions, offered thoughtful suggestions, and made the ordering experience smooth and enjoyable. Their level of care and customer service truly great!

I ordered a custom cake for my daughter’s birthday party! The staff at Mia’s bakery were very flexible and accommodating with our ideas and cake design. They went above and beyond to add the disco balls and stars. We couldn’t have been happier with the final product, the cake was a massive hit with kids and parents (the Brooklyn Blackout was so tasty). Thoroughly recommend Mia’s for custom cakes.

Mia’s was PACKED with a giant line right before our big snow storm, which should tell you something about how locals feel about the necessity of getting Mia’s before we expect the city to shut down. Mia’s is a beloved local establishment in downtown BK, but they also have locations on the UES and Times Square. Aesthetically, this is a super cute spot where you can grab your goodies to-go from a super cute 1950s style dessert counter, or you can stay and eat your sweets at their tables with a delicious hot drink (which you can also get to-go; their coffee is really good!). While I didn’t think this is an old establishment, they clearly have a grasp on all the NY dessert classics. You want Italian butter cookies? You can buy them by the pound. Classic diner array of cake slices? Done. Cupcakes? Brownies? A beautiful little display of colorful macarons? Flaky croissants? Cannolis? Got them all. I personally think their Italian rainbow cookies are a testament to their quality. I have had some truly terrible rainbow cookies: I think most New Yorkers know that a rainbow cookie CAN be good, but it’s usually a disappointing and dry experience. The rainbow cookie at Mia’s is the best I’ve ever had, hands down. It is MOIST and you can actually taste the often indiscernible jam between the cake layers. And it is a flavorful, bright jam! I think it’s the same jam in their Linzer Torte cookies, which is also delish. Shoutout as well to the soft almond cookies, lobster tails (vanilla is my preference) and Brooklyn blackout cake.

Ordered some cupcakes here for a friend's birthday and they were delicious! We placed the order online and picked it up for the day we needed it and the process was very smooth. Would recommend if you have a special occasion coming up or just want a little sweet treat!