Miss Nellie's

My wife and I had an incredible meal at Miss Nellie’s — easily one of the best dining experiences in NYC. From the moment we walked in, we were impressed by the chic, yet cozy ambiance that set the stage for a memorable evening. We started with the Caviar Lobster Rolls, three mini rolls filled with perfectly cooked lobster, topped with caviar and a hint of lemon. Paired with crisp house chips, this dish was a perfect balance of indulgence and freshness. The Lemon Ricotta Tortellini was a highlight — the lemon ricotta cream paired beautifully with fresno and piquillo peppers, garlic, and white wine. It was rich, bright, and utterly comforting. The Pan-Fried Snapper stole the show. The snapper was perfectly crispy and tender, and the broccolini, roasted peppers, and olive salsa complemented it beautifully. The cocktails were equally exceptional. The Filthy One, made with olive oil fat-washed Bombay gin and blue cheese olives, was a bold, unforgettable take on a classic martini. But Fogg & Fancies was the real showstopper — a bourbon-based cocktail presented inside a stack of books that released a cloud of smoke when opened, adding a dramatic flair to the already delicious drink. Every dish, every drink, and every detail was crafted with care, making this a top-tier dining experience. The service was impeccable, and the overall vibe of Miss Nellie’s made it a night to remember. We can't wait to return and highly recommend it to anyone looking for an unforgettable meal in NYC.

What an amazing experience all around. We were celebrating an early birthday before attending a show. Once we walked in we were greeted by every staff member that we saw and I was given a cute hand written birthday card. The drinks, the food and of course the service were all top notch. Cailinn our waitress was so nice and made us feel right at home. I got the French dip sandwich which was excellent. They also gave us a birthday desert on the house, which made my night. I would highly recommend this restaurant! You will not be disappointed.

The atmosphere and service in this restaurant is the reason I’d come back! Our waitress Sam was very friendly and attentive to our needs. The art and decorations here are unbelievably stunning. The food was pretty good, but aside from the Lemon Ricotta Tortellini, it was fairly average in my family’s opinion. My mom and sister ordered drinks and my sister loved her espresso martini. We also got the Mediterranean Dips app and I liked the pita and hummus. The chicken parm meatballs were pretty good and my mom ordered the smashburger and said it was average. If you plan on coming here for a meal, I recommend getting a cocktail and the Lemon Ricotta Tortellini. I typically hate citrus, but this meal was a mild lemony flavor that was so good. Our waitress gave us complimentary shots at the end of our meal and was so kind to give me a non-alcoholic option since she didn’t think I drank (which is accurate).

Came here for brunch as a walk-in. Had the Mc Nellie's B.E.C.- bacon, egg, hash brown, and cheese with sauce on a toasted English muffin - absolutely delicious! The combination was perfectly balanced and the sauce gave it an amazing flavor. The ambiance is unique and charming, a cozy spot that feels both casual and special. The service was great, everyone was friendly and attentive. Definitely want to come back and try dinner next time!

What a dreamy spot! We had a reservation & couldn’t leave the bar. It was too fun. Incredible cocktails. Decent food (we loved the crispy tuna/rice), great music, and an overall fantastic vibe! Stopped in here before seeing a show, and would absolutely come back.

MIss Nellies is a fun victorian decorated restaurant with carpets on the ceilings and several different rooms for seating. I think it is usually pretty busy and lively and hard to get a reservation if you try close to your desired date but easy if you do it a little in advance. Overall this restaurant was a fun spot with some good food options. We went for brunch so can’t comment on lunch or dinner some regulars were speaking with said it was very good. Unfortunately they have batched cocktails which is a negative for me. The dirty martini looked nice when served but was quite small for the price and not a favorite for my taste. It may have been the gin they used, but it was rather bland. The chopped salad was good but think the name is misleading. It is simply a mixed green salad. There was nothing chopped at all. Tasty but not what was expected based on the name. Smash burger was the best bite. Cooked well but still juicy and melt in your mouth delicious. Fries were extremely well cooked very crispy and the right amount of salt. We split the burger between two people and it was a great portion. We ended with a short stack of bee pollen pancakes, again one order split between two people and it was a perfect dessert. We ordered it with everything on the side, butter and syrup which I highly recommend because then you can taste each component and decide what you want on them. They are served very hot, a real plus, and have crunch on the outside but were light and fluffy inside. A really very good pancake. Overall enjoyed the food at this restaurant

Our server Jaime was an excellent server very attentive and knowledgeable. Such a sweet soul very easy to talk to! Nellie’s is a perfect spot for any occasion the food was fantastic and the service was seven better. 10/10

Me and my partner are traveling from out of town and saw this location on media platforms. The food was fantastic. The spicy chicken appetizer was delicious. That was my boyfriend’s favorite part. We both got the chicken parm meatballs which were so good. We got dessert and drinks as well 10/10. The highlight of the night was our server Noah. Noah was fantastic! So attentive and friendly. We are definitely coming back here when we travel in the future.