Eric T
Google
Mustard's Bagels in Culver City is definitely a cute spot and I was genuinely excited to try it. The bagels in the display looked amazing -- super pretty, fresh, and honestly had me thinking this was going to be my new go-to bagel place.
Immediately greeted with a warm welcome. The inside is small and has a little walk up counter to order but nowhere to sit inside.
The prices are definitely on the higher side, but we decided to pre-order some bagels and cream cheese to-go and give it a fair shot.
I usually judge a bagel place by their everything bagel (my all-time favorite), and unfortunately... it was a little underwhelming. I love a good sourdough-style bagel with a crunchy outside, but this one was almost too crunchy all the way through, without enough softness or chew on the inside. It felt more hard than balanced. Dare I even say a little burnt?
That being said, the cream cheeses were delicious and probably the highlight for me. We tried the plain and salmon cream cheese (up charge).
We also tried the Nori bagel and I wasn't a fan. The flavor was way too fishy for my taste and just didn't work for me.
On the positive side, the plain salted bagel was solid and probably the one I enjoyed the most.
Overall, I'm glad I tried it, but it's not my favorite bagel spot in the area. Might come back for the cream cheese, but the bagels themselves didn't totally hit the mark for me.