My Pie Pizzeria Romana

Pizza restaurant · Upper West Side

My Pie Pizzeria Romana

Pizza restaurant · Upper West Side

1

166 W 72nd St, New York, NY 10023

Photos

My Pie Pizzeria Romana by null
My Pie Pizzeria Romana by null
My Pie Pizzeria Romana by null
My Pie Pizzeria Romana by null
My Pie Pizzeria Romana by null
My Pie Pizzeria Romana by null
My Pie Pizzeria Romana by null
My Pie Pizzeria Romana by null
My Pie Pizzeria Romana by null
My Pie Pizzeria Romana by null
My Pie Pizzeria Romana by null
My Pie Pizzeria Romana by null
My Pie Pizzeria Romana by null
My Pie Pizzeria Romana by null
My Pie Pizzeria Romana by null
My Pie Pizzeria Romana by null
My Pie Pizzeria Romana by null
My Pie Pizzeria Romana by null
My Pie Pizzeria Romana by null
My Pie Pizzeria Romana by null

Highlights

Grab a slice of Roman-style pinsa with a perfectly crispy crust and inventive toppings at this cozy spot that’s a local pizza gem.  

Featured in Eater
Placeholder
Placeholder

166 W 72nd St, New York, NY 10023 Get directions

mypiepizzeria.com
@mypiepizzeria

$ · Menu

Information

Static Map

166 W 72nd St, New York, NY 10023 Get directions

+1 212 787 7200
mypiepizzeria.com
@mypiepizzeria

$ · Menu

Features

Tap to pay

Last updated

Mar 4, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@eater

"My Pie Pizzeria Romana offers Roman pinsa pizzas with a mixed-flour crust that undergoes a 48-hour period of rising, providing a wide choice of toppings. The pizzas come out lush and crunchy with toasted cheese spilled over the edge. The zucchini artichoke and the parma prosciutto cotto are particularly notable, along with Italian sodas and several desserts." - Robert Sietsema

A Delightful Roman Pizza to Try — and Other Cheap Eats - Eater NY
View Postcard for My Pie Pizzeria Romana

Reid M

Google
Delicious pizza slices to order and great vegan options. The crust is nice and crispy and the toppings are generous and fresh. I highly recommend it! Pro tip: one slice is probably enough food for one person, the slices are cut in half so it's easy to share two different slices.

Fariah Amber

Google
I really felt like having pizza and loved the idea of this place. Pre made slices so you can try different types! We had the mushroom ones which were oh so delicious. The spinach artichoke was good too but the mushroom as amazing!! The crust is ridiculously delicious. I wish all pizza had crust like this! The seating area is limited but I absolutely LOVED the look. Check the pics out! I would definitely want to be back because there are other flavors I want to try!

Evgeniia Guliaeva

Google
Love this place and their pizza. One of the best in the city. Eggplant Parmesan, Zucchini Artichoke, and Grandma are my favorites. Their vegan options look so good that I even want to try it next time I'm there. By the way, people who work here are very nice and can always give you some good recommendations. Thank you, guys, for your business!

Samantha Anthony

Google
Was looking forward to trying this place when I heard they had vegan slices. The slices itself was good and loaded with yummy veggies, but the cheese was not even melted a little bit. It was stringy and kind of tasteless. Vegan cheese can totally melt, it's just about getting the right cooking time. I'd advise a vegan slice without cheese if you're lactose intolerant or vegan.

Chris Quartly

Google
Nice and cheap option before a show at the beacon, the slices are double-sized so just be aware of that before you order (basically one slice is really two slices). The meatball was excellent although I felt the zucchini/artichoke slice desperately needed some salt to tie it together. All in all, very good pinsa.

Jack Lawson

Google
For $6 a slice this is a great spot to stop. In reality you are getting 2 slices...they are bigger than you may first think (or than I first thought anyway). Small space, not many seats to stop and eat but perfect for a grab and go pizza shop! The sausage was certainly not my favorite (nor will I ever order that one again). Stick with the classics and you can’t go wrong though. Pep and margarita were spot on.

Sofi Khmara

Google
Wow! Really great vegan pizza! Good flavors, but the crust is something special. So grateful they're there!

Brian Berger

Google
My girlfriend and I stumbled upon this neighborhood gem. Definitely top 3 pizza places I've ever had. We had the margherita, eggplant, arugula and caprese slices. Delicious and appropriately filling!