Daniel M.
Yelp
Yes, it does get five stars, and hits this mark for a bunch of reasons. Years ago, every town of any consequence had one, or two, or three, dining establishments where a person could get sandwiches, a burger, fries, ice cream, or breakfast. The drink of choice was coffee, and maybe a Coke. Maybe this restaurant was a strictly local place, or maybe it was part of a chain, but it served great comfort food that everyone enjoyed.
Today, you can't find as many of these small restaurants any more, as they have been displaced by fast causal eateries, or locations specializing in more exotic fare, or perhaps a luxury place. Fortunately, there is still the Newport Creamery, still doing it well in Middletown, right by where the chain started. What you get is a menu similar to what local restaurants always used to serve, with the standards and standbys, along with a small seafood selection (it's right by the ocean, so why not), and ice cream.
And, of course, there is the Awful Awful, and no trip to Newport Creamery at any of its locations would be complete without one. It's a big, supercharged milk shake that is Awful big and Awful good, hence the name. I have been getting them for over 40 years and they never disappoint. It was the perfect chaser to my burger and fries which is as good as I have always had every time I've gone to one of Newport Creamery's locations.
There is a window serving ice cream for takeout and, while I've had it before, I had to forego it on my most recent visit, as the Awful Awful had me hitting my limit for the afternoon. If there was anything better than the food itself, it had to have been the service. Our server, whom I believe was from down South, was knowledgeable about everything (and I mean everything) on the menu, made sure everything was prepared exactly as we wanted, and never hovered over us as we enjoyed a very memorable lunch. She herself would have warranted five stars!
I've been going to Newport Creamery locations for over 40 years, and Newport Creamery still does regular food incredibly well. Many of its competitors have changed or gone by the wayside, but this great place still produces real food for real people, and does it as well as ever. Keep up the great work.